How Good Was Peyton Manning Actually?

Ryan fizzzssssttpatrick is the smartest

My favorite QB

Not good enough

This guy made playing QB look so easy in the NFL
No1 overall picks will forever be compared to the sheriff

Hes the second best QB of all time behind Tom Brady..... Peyton was a very Talented QB

So, just no mention of the 98' orange bowl then? I'm sure Peyton came back to do more than just "beat the gators"

Besides TB, PM was the most dangerous regular season QB for quite a long time.

didnt Marvin kill somebody?

I HATED playing Manning in Madden back in the day!!! Lol

It was not 12 years. 1995 Jim Harbaugh lead the Colts to the AFC Championship against Pittsburgh.

Peyton to this day is the smartest offensive player in the history of the league.

Payton is overrated didn't do anything in the playoffs

I'll take Manning over Brady anyway. Peyton didn't need to deflate balls or spy on the other team.

brady better

I’m a life long pats fan I mean decades before Brady came and the wife n I where talking what if he didn’t have Brady would he have more super bowls wins? Good question we will never know

Yeah, it was not Peyton, it was the team. Something was just not right.

I still think manning should have won the mvp in 2011. They went from a double digit win a year team to the first pick in the draft. I dunno. Just my viewpoint on the meaning of MVP

In my opinion, a lot of players that are called "chokers" were actually overachievers that did more with less and then when the competition gets better they tend to loss by a large margin.
If a player is really rattled in pressure situations, they usually loss close games at the end. Maybe I'm completely wrong but it seems to make sense in my, very scare, mind

as a patriots fan, no player was more feared and respected than peyton

Peyton is the best ever

It really was crazy back then. Peyton would throw ~30 tds, 4,000-4,700 yds, and win 12+ games year after year and it was just normal

It's amazing what you can accomplish with a good defense

The best regular season quarterback of all time 🤘😂

I love Peyton he is such a staple of great QBs. That being said, I would love to see a similar video of how great Tony Romo was. Undrafted, put into horrible positions and still put up insane numbers. No im not saying Romo is Peyton. But the come up story is only supressed solely because he played for Dallas. Had he played for a smaller market team, he would be a fan favorite and an underdog story. I still think had Romo played instead of Dak, we coild have seen one of the most potent offenses ever.

ALL TIME RECORDS ARE LONGEVITY AWARDS. PERIOD.

I swear, Eli and Peyton switch uniform in post seasons

He’s definitely great. I don’t want to just compare Super Bowl rings because it’s a team sport. But I can’t help but feel like his second Super Bowl he had very little to do with and his two Super Bowl losses were bad ones on his legacy. It’s also hard to not compare that with Tom Brady who’s Super Bowl achievements and failures garner more respect.

Manning was the best regular season qb of all time. If he had two more rings he’d be the goat. Even if Tom still had all of his.

Really good at t-bagging.

He's thrown more pick plays too - complete joke.

Not as good as the GOAT Brady

The thing about GOATs, be it in the NFL or NBA ... they always think other people were better. Thats why they wil always be the GOAT.

He is the most under achieved greatest QB of all time

Seems like he was pretty good

Manning is the greatest regular season QB of all-time. He was pretty good in the playoffs too with two SB rings.

Omaha said hike

He is my favorite quarterback all time

I respected Peyton over Brady because of morals and honor. To me Peyton will always trump Brady eventho Brady did win more.

Good enough to win almost 29% of Tom Brady’s super bowl win total. Good enough to finally match his statistically average younger brother in super bowl wins in his final season.

Elite mind limited physically

so he was pretty good

The greatest ever. He made everyone around him a super star

I grew up with the Baltimore Colts with my Dad, when they left Baltimore and became the Indy Colts we began to enjoy Football once again. Once again I purchased so many Colt Collections. When Peyton left I was finished with the Colts!! Peyton was a true player who enjoyed playing football!!!

Is False Swipe Gaming translating into the sports world?? Wow! Cool!

At 37 years old, Peyton found hgh 😂😂😂😂

I like him better as a commercial star, Fritos scoops still need some star power!

As a person born and raised in Indiana and living right outside of Indianapolis, I’ve never been more disgusted then I was when the colts did Peyton the way they did. Peyton Manning for president.

There's no debate. Peyton was, and still is, great

Not sure I understands. Tom Brady holds all qb records for tds, yard, and completions