Комментарии:
Likely less forgotten than intentionally hidden, like many such atrocities that have occurred throughout history.
ОтветитьWhy in the English Caribbean Islands there are NO indigenous natives and in the Spanish Caribbean islands there are? Why in Australia and New Zealand there are NO indigenous natives and in the Philippines there are? Why in the states of the USA with English name there are NO indigenous natives and in the states of USA with Spanish name there are?
Spain did not exterminate indigenous native. England did.
Man, this guy rabold on about so much but didn't say anything at all
ОтветитьMaybe so, but I don't think the overestimation of the dead from the 9/11 attack governed the US's response. I think the populace at large was almost crazed with outrage that anyone dared to attack US civilians on home soil. Only severe military ferocity could match what was in people's hearts. The attack on the Pentagon was barely covered. Probably the Pentagon wanted it that way. I think for the Bush administration it was an opportunity to settle an old grudge.
ОтветитьIt wasn't a Black Legend, it was true. Jews, Protestants and others were tortured and murdered by the Spanish Catholics. That is historical reality.
ОтветитьAs a Hispanic-American , I can tell you the Black Legend exists as a tool of Cultural Colonialism , to deny us our identity and History and keep us subservient .
ОтветитьDon't forget the third tower that fell a little later. The media ignores that completely. And more. But your point is well taken. Thank you.
ОтветитьGreshsm college has been caught misleading people, luckily for people like myself, we read the old books, not rewritten lies, the Spanish Inquisition was Spain throwing out black Jews, also killing them, the kings and popes ordered the black Jews to be sold as slaves and to be raised as Christians, professor tudor parfait teaches us the truth, you people are not of the truth, the semitic races is black, they're afroasiatics, afro gives the game away, stop lying to your students, teach real history, not rewritten trash
ОтветитьAtrocities.
ОтветитьSiento que muchos españoles han visto el video pero no han entendido el punto jaja
ОтветитьWhat fascinates me is the entropic nature of atrocities when the realisation was deemed an act of evil ? I guess Christian empathy changed how those in power reflect on acts of organised violence in terms of numbers , morality, and guilt of God's judgment on those involved . Francisco De Quevedo views of the Spanish Inquisition give an interesting insight into the Catholic mind set in the early 16th century.
ОтветитьAtrocities for over 20 minutes a quarter of the lecture I can't stand it what about the SPANISH INQUISITION
ОтветитьThis is clearly not unbiased. But, it is interesting nonetheless.
ОтветитьFacts not fiction...Mexico is 50 % Amerindian the US is less than 1%. The Spanish didn't exterminate they assimilted
ОтветитьFair enough.. thank you from Saudi Arabia 🇸🇦
ОтветитьNear 3000 persons in 340 is less 9 persons per year in the whole spanish empire. It's seems not to be a atrocity or genocide. It's seems more propaganda by the enemies of the spanish.
ОтветитьThanks for posting. A great lecture. I’ve enjoyed every one of Dr Ryie’s presentations
ОтветитьThere was NO peaceful convivence in the Peninsula ever. It eas a difficul cohabitation. That is was Reconquista succeeded
ОтветитьJews were expelled from other countries long before than Spain
ОтветитьSpanish Inquisition was far more fair than English Star Chamber and French Lettre de Cachet
ОтветитьInquisition was far more fair way to manage intolerance that any WASP one
ОтветитьNo matter what, WASPs always consider no WASPs as under humans, they always find justification to feel entitled to do any atrocity, and endorse them to someone else. The problematic relationship between protestants and guilt
ОтветитьThank you 🙌👏👏
ОтветитьThe 'political fog' of atrocities today is well exemplified by the Hamas atrocity in Israel. The 'fog' being well supplied by a large portion of Palestinians themselves in conjunction with the political left and portions of the media.....who would much rather turn a blind eye
ОтветитьAre you saying that the Jews exaggerated the holocaust because they were ideologically and religiously against the Nazis? Is 6,000,000 dead Jews simply the product of polemical discourse? If not then why should any of the murders of Christians, Jews, and Muslims in the middle ages at the hands of the Spanish inquisitors be considered polemical exaggeration? This is nothing more than a Catholic defense of the Spanish Inquisition by white washing the devastating atrocities of their brutal history.
ОтветитьIt was the Catholic Inquisition. The Christian Inquisition, even. Indeed, anti-catholic monarchs had their fair share of atrocity.
ОтветитьI expected him to mention the inquisition.
ОтветитьDepuis la France merci il est grand temps que la vérité sorte !
ОтветитьThe catholic church has robbed, facilitated and continues to Rob black jews / the house of Israel of their property and persons till this day😢
ОтветитьNotice how the atrocities today are connected to Anglo Protestant countries
ОтветитьThey did even worse to Portugal
ОтветитьIt bears mentioning that one of the reasons why early modern Spain had such a high Jewish population was because they had migrated there following exile from almost all other western European kingdoms/cities. It's quite hypocritical then that in the black legend only Spain seems to be remembered for the expulsion of the Jews in 1492. This also invalidates the speakers claim that this was the precursor to modern anti-semitism. Indeed you could argue that Spain was the last medieval kingdom to expel the jews, not the first.
ОтветитьHmmmm No ...the destruction of twin towers WAS an atrocity. How ridiculous to say that only its coverage on TV made it an atrocity.... 🧐🙄
Ответить- England, France, Germany, Hungary, Austria... expelled and killed the Jews in the S.XII, S.XIII, S.XIV. = Nobody care
- Spain expels Jews and Muslims for enslaving Catholics for centuries (Al-Andalus). = Everyone "let's hate Spain and the inquisition".
The Spanish Inquisition always gave you 30 days notice. So everyone expected the Spanish Inquisition.
ОтветитьTorquemade was actually a Jewish converso
Ответитьthe black legend is almost entirely false. no one takes it seriously in the academia.
Ответитьthe inquisition was the most humanistic court of law of that time. the black legend is almost entirely false.
ОтветитьThe muslim population was a lot higher then the jewish population in spain
ОтветитьIslam is a uniquely violent religion, what! How have you reached that conclusion. Cast your eyes over to Ireland and perhaps the reformation if you want to sample Christianity at its best. Not to mention the Catholic atrocities in the Americas. I could go on.
ОтветитьBrown Jessica Smith Steven Williams Ronald
ОтветитьSame Spaniards are completely ignorant about what they did to taino indians in the Americas.There was a Spaniard man named Bartholomew De Las Casas who has witnessed the atrocities committed against Native Americans.These same Spaniards should understand how cruel the encomienda system was from enslaving natives to burning them alive to raping their women and Today Spanish ignore these kind of atrocities what their ancestors did in the name of Black legend
ОтветитьSociopathy is survival
ОтветитьWhat an excellent lecturer!
ОтветитьComparing anti-abortion to vegans is in itself is a statement of belief.
He means: Animals are being killed.
The slavers who killed those slaves thought the same thing.
The so called Moral Self-restraint which religions are supposed to foster is no more than a hypocritical facade beneath the which lies the roiling cauldron of repressed human passion.
ОтветитьHe didn’t list it as an example - perhaps unconfident among the political sensitivities of our own time, but then perhaps he won’t agree - but in my opinion the Holocaust, greatest singular atrocity in the known history of human civilisation, has been shamefully misused by the Israeli government and establishment in apologia for indefensible mass state violence against the Palestinians in the name of defending Israel’s Jewish citizens, an exact case and possibly the greatest example of the pattern he describes at the beginning of the lecture.
Ответить