South Africa's "White Genocide"?

watch serpentza vids ,he was born and raised in SA
this guy should debate him

I think your video didn’t address the elephant in the room- the stadiums full of people singing “shoot the boer”

What happened when mugabe redistributed the farms from whites. Remind me how that worked out, which country now has as many materially and intellectually wealthy blacks as Rhodesia once did.

Just because we joined Eu

Academics. There's a lot of information in your video that you seemingly deliberately failed to include. Like, for example, the 'indigenous' population. Unless you're talking about the Khoisan, ALL people in South Africa are migrants. The Zulu nation did not even exist before 1800. They derive from the Ndebele and Nguni. Bantu fro north west Africa.

Second, you have no idea what you're talking about. It's clear you've never been there, or are deliberately lying.

Third - citizenship was never 'stripped' from the Bantu. They never had it to begin with.

🌟... "Despite the Mountain of Undeniable Crimes against Humanity and Undeniable Historical Facts known to All, If You Are Not Careful Those Who Colonized and Seized Others' Land and Established the Slave Trade, Odious Systems of Slavery and Apartheid Will Attempt to Pass Themselves Off as the Victims of the Odious Systems of Discrimination and Dehumanization of the Afflictions of the Filthy Colonial Era and Colonialism" ... ! ! !
🌟🌟

These are not "claims." The evidence is crystal clear. Almost a million white South Africans have FLED over the last 25 years, 15%+ of the population. It is a state-sponsored genocide, and YOUR POLITICAL RULERS find it inconvenient to acknowledge. The CLASS OF PEOPLE who control media and education LIKE THE GENICIDE and dont want you or anyone to be bothered by it

"not technically genocide" - all the racially motivates INHUMAN VIOLENCE.... this usually the first "let the white people be raped and murdered without response" argument. Been this exact dialectic for decades...

Bunch of unrelated factoids and historcal inaccuracies thru the lens of pr - YOU are paying for this thru tax dollars

SA is a racist loony bin and it is hurtling towards the abyss. Farms are under attack and the ANC govt is trying to copy the outwardly genocidal socialist party. There are very good reasons why people laugh at and or ignore msm and polite opinion. If you remain BBC-style blind to the unfolding collapse and barbarity of SA, then I don't think there's much that can be said to you.

Why is it so hard to just say that raping and murdering people's families is a bad thing, and that BLACK South Africans... shouldn't do it, and, the SA government is complicit, and... THEY SHOULDN'T BE? Why is your soul so evil that you cannot say that.

Go look at the real stats, the mass evacuation of whites over 20 years, the POLICE ACCOUNTS of monsterous violence for no other reason than racial hate of whites. WHEN are we going to say its not ok? How much moral courage does that even take? Trump and some dumb song? ARE NOT RELEVANT FACTORS.

Why does the president of South Africa let a party that openly calls for white genocide exist? The obvious answer is he is afraid he will lose votes to it. That party is "only" at 10% because the president isn't opposing it. He could ban the party or members or convict them of crimes. He doesn't. The president of Nigeria admitted he doesn't do much of anything to stop the genocide of Christians in Nigeria because he can't afford to oppose it. This video is extremely dishonest and fishing for easy views. Have some guts or don't talk about the topic.

Wow. This is certainly a very biased and media-mainstream viewpoint. He mentions the 5 points of genocide and we hit 4 out of the 5!! Aka, this IS a genocide. Brushed over facts, distorted some others... with the narrative we are all supposed to believe. These years of propaganda certainly stuck.

I don't know how this can be claimed as an unbiased report when no effort is made to look at actual evidence of killings and persecutions of farmers in South Africa. Just sweeping it away and calling it 'discredited' is not a proper analysis.

Lots of people gotta understand that facts do not care about your feelings and that Musk and Trump's claims are not backed up by available evidence.

White genocide has been going on in South Africa since the 1980s. That's how we got so many South African medical school instructors at Stanford University around that time. Look at the faculty list yourself. This is a pure propaganda piece from ANC sympathizers who continue longstanding disinformation. Don't believe me? Ask anyone who has fled South Africa yourself: They ALL say the same thing. And it's NOT what is said here.

Lies never last. Who exactly is fooling president Trump?! He looked so convinced that there is a genocide in SA. I wonder what was president Ramaposa thinking.

Ramaphosa literally threw himself into a cauldron going to the White House..got roasted in front of the world & the media & Trump has got them all itching triggered..😅

when trump highlighted it its hard to denied it especially those who do it post a lot of propaganda and graves in social media

I just listened to the May 25,2025 edition of The Rubin Report where he interviewedRobert Hersov. for a lot more detail. Only a stick from our government will break the now Iran bribed Ramaphosama government. He has yet to explain how $Ms were found in his house.

If the S.A. government does not yet desire tontine another genocidal step towards White farmers, why did ntheynpass the law?

Why dont you come and farm here and learn some Afrikaans? I recomend the North West province.

I have enjoyed watching your videos for many years and found them very informative and generally un biased. That said anything to do with Trump you seem to take a strong stance.
I agree that genocide is a strong term but there is definitely some level of ethnic cleansing going on. Having travelled extensively around SA and have many SA friends this is obvious to most observers.
If it was any other group rather than Europeans having land taken off them without compensation there would be uproar.
For whatever reason there is a group of politicians, elites and observers who have chosen for years to ignore crimes and aggressions against mainly european populations. Whether that be South African situation, the large scale rape of British girls in UK, terror attacks all over Europe by people who were imported without the consent of the population.
This has led to a wide spread resentment of the "establishment" and I fear for what is coming.

No insight in this video. It was like a Wikipedia readout followed by a Vox analysis.

I’m Canadian and there is so much similarities between policies of colonial rule in South Africa and Canada. Indigenous people were systematically colonized and their life was legislated and were resettled in bad areas. Those areas toxic have no running water , crimes are high, and poverty is everywhere. I think it’s up to South Africans of all races to find a way to deal with their horrible past and move on. Donald Trump and his circle who are anti DEI, abortion, immigration, identity politics are pushing so hard “white genocide” propaganda.

Thank you for seeing past the lies and being impartial.

Thank you for this information my good sir

Did you research all the horrific murders Mr Prof James ?

Will it take the death of the last white person in SA before anyone finally sees what is going on?

Ramaphosa: Farm murders in South Africa is just ordinary crime.
Grok: 1.15% to 1.34% of South Africa’s population has died due to murder over the last 30 years (1995–2025). The murder rate for white commercial farmers is higher, at 2.2%–4.7%. White farmers face a disproportionate risk.
On account of murder rate, South African society can be called barbaric. Murder on white farmers is twice to more than four times as barbaric.

This guy is whitewashing the white genocide taking place in South Africa. Racism towards any group needs to be soundly condemned and this person is doing a great injustice by tolerating it.

if only facts mattered

As a so called " coloured" South African living abroad, the pain and scars never disappear. As a Christian I am called to forgive - and I do.. Forget? That's easier said than done.. The harm that the Apartheid government perpetrated on the disadvantaged majority will take many generations to wash away. But can the now new majority government of the ANC learn from these mistakes? Or are they repeating the same mistakes? I pray for healing and fairness in South Africa. There is no country like it. The more time I spend away from it, the more I yearn for it. As for genocide? Trump needs to stop being led by the nose by Elon Musk and start reading his history books.
Thank you for your honest appraisal of the situation PROF James 🙏

I'm so glad you're talking about this professor..my wife is South African and I really wanted to know what's going on. Happy to see you always prof 🙂👍

I'm from Canada and every white south African I've ever met living here has a story.

THE UNITED STATES HASN’T CLOSED IT’S DOORS TO ANYONE WHO WISHES TO APPLY FOR ENTRY LEGALLY.
THE UNITED STATES IS REMOVING THE ILLEGALS WHO CROSSED INTO THE US ILLEGALLY. PERIOD.
FURTHERMORE, IF SOMEONE COMES TO THE US ON A VISA AND VIOLATES THE RULES OF THE VISA, THEIR VISA WILL BE DENIED AND THEY WILL BE RETURNED TO THEIR OWN NATION.
THIS IS ALL QUITE EASY TO UNDERSTAND.
ALLOWING THE MURDER OF WHITE FARMERS WHICH WAS BEING REPORTED FIRST BY SOUTH AFRICAN FAMILIES, NOT ELON, SHOULD HAVE BEEN TAKEN SERIOUSLY, BUT WE CAN SEE THERE IS A VERY CLEAR BIAS TOWARDS WHITE PEOPLE IN SOUTH AFRICA.

I’m a south farmer and listening to your accent i presume you to be british and wonder if you have ever been to the real rural south africa?Have you ever been tho the walls of remembrance at nampopark? Most farmers are ex military and are extremely well trained with extremely well guarded homes thus making it difficult for attackers. There are about 30000 farmers left in sa and the murder rate is 4 to 1 compared to the rest of the population making it one of the most dangerous professions in the world. Use this information or not but i can tell you that we are the last stand a once first world country falling into chaos and destruction

if you dont call 1 farmer killed on average every 3 days there farms confederate with out compensation a genocidal act you say there no such thing as anti semitic

The standard for accepting refugies is not 'Are you fleeing genocide?' So you sir are besides the point. The terim those who live in glass houses should not throw stones is relavant here, South Africa is the last country that should go to the ICC. the UK too with the situation of law enforcement towards its own people, not in the American South of the 1950s but in the woke 21st century makes the holyer than though attitude you reek of unatractive.

Nice using data that south Africa has given

There is no genocide in south Africa , the evils are lieing to justify their evil doings in south Africa and in America , , pathological lias 😡😡😡😡😡

Not to mention, even IF there's a white genocide in South Africa (which there isn't), it's racist of the Trump administration to grant refugee status ONLY to white people while revoking/denying refugee status for brown and black people who are also escaping conflict.

Let me share something that happened in 1992 that most don't know or forgot it even happened. In 1992 Apartheid South Africa under the rule of Nationalist party held a referendum about whether to end apartheid or not. ONLY whites could vote. we had to ask permission to end evil.

2,799,796 votes
1,924,186 voted yes apartheid must end.
875,610 voted no it shouldn't end.

So 68.73% whites voted for ending apartheid and 31.27% voted Big Fat NO.

One question among lots is what happened to the 31.27% who refused? this might just show you the state of South Africa. There is and has always been this element in South Africa that undermined and still is undermining the efforts of South African to eradicate this plaque. Yes and a big yes crime is our problem, Genocide no.

Racist!

Personally I don’t believe it’s an ambush when my country expected it , although our government wasn’t prepared for some odd reason yet they claimed that they where prepared the outcome showed us something else .

This week, President Trump ambushed another leader at the White House. This time, it was the turn of the South African President, Cyril Ramaphosa, who faced a full-scale onslaught of allegations of a “white genocide”. But while claims of mass killings have gained political traction in US right-wing circles, international observers have rejected the claims. So, what do you think? Is there any truth to the accusations? If not, what should be done to counter the claims? As always, I look forward to your thoughts and comments.