The Authenticity of Ghadeer

Abu bakar sadiq was on haq umar ra was on haq you shia keep banging your heads against a wall, what was will allways be you can't change it. You shia suni breveli sufi you all practice your own innovations Bidah so rectify your selves, divide you stand that's why you have no power

Muslims are divided because the do not a leader to unify them and worse they want to impose their brand on Islam on other sects, not respecting each other's interpretation.
Hence this weakness is taken advantage of and hence the use abuse and slaughter of Muslims.
THINK IF MUSLIMS HAD A LEADER PROPHET MUHAMMED OR HAZRAT ALI (P/B/U/THEM) TODAY. WHERE WOULD MUSLIMS BE???

ONE Amanat, Holy Quran, nothing else/

Allahumma salli ala Muhammed ve alee Muhammed 🌹❤️🇹🇷

ALLAHUMMA SALLE ALA MUHAMMADUN WA ALI MUHAMMAD

Machalla

All Muslims Sunnis and Shias accept the tradition of Ghadeer but look at it from a different point of view.We have to tolerate both the Sunni and Shia views concerning this matter as long as there is no abuse against one another.

Please make dua for our shia brothers and sisters for them to realize to leave this judgement to ALLAH most high and unite with their sunni family as one ummah this argument brings nothing but hatred and wars and both sides are wrong because Satan drew the line and both parties are waging wars and spill blood because of this line

This sounds more like a conspiracy that started after the death of hadrat Ali all this ( they would be they could be about poets people getting beaten up not enough supporters no one stood with Hadrat Ali ) all these smells like a conspiracy none of arguments makes sense

My question is what if Hadrat Ali deny all these claims on the day of judgement

Then why did hadrat Ali recognise the ridership of Hadrat Abu Bakr and Omar sorry does not make sense

This opens a lot of questions that's even senseless to question

No one was true Muslim during the lifetime of Prophet SAW, nor any one has been after him.

Quran 25:74 shows very clear that every rightous believer can be IMAM(leader) of believers. Meaning not only from bloodline of Prophet a.s.
(25:74) "who are prone to pray: "Our Lord! Grant us that our spouses and our offspring be a joy to our eyes, and do make us the IMAMA (leaders) of the God-fearing."

Ghadeer was true event when Prophet a s held Khutba,but Ghadeer has nothing to do about appointing of Ali as successor.
In Ghadeer,Prophet a.s was showing to muslims that Ali should be their CLOSE FRIEND(MAWLA),after a dispute some muslims had with Ali about share of war spoils.
Quran 25:74 shows that every rightous believer can be IMAM(leader) of rightous believers.

Mashaallah ❤❤❤

I think the issue is in assumption that Maula Ali is like any other person and not miraculous which is incorrect and when riwayat being followed shows the martaba of ahlulbaiyt. In regards to why maula Ali did not fight or stressed back for power its very simple to protect Islam a war between Muslims at that time when peoples thoughts are divided would lead to bloodshed.

Please create more content liek this in english and also english videos about answering sunni shobahat

This is is famous to people in Persia. But of the 120,000 people attending from Yemen, Egypt.. Nobody cares. People from Persia didn't attend because they still Majoos. Where did they get this info? Even Ali didn't care of this event because he did not fight for his Immamate /caliphate. Even story from the Qur'an, Prophet Noh's son, that emaan cannot be inherited. Logical answer is Majoos fabricated the story of Ghadir khum.

Ali had disobeyed the commandment of Allah for he didn't fight for his Immamate.

Brilliant video

Mashaallah...if interested in reading about the historical events and politics during the time of the Prophet saww, Please Google for the book, "Then I was Guided"...it gave answers to my questions and helped me understand things...worth spending a few hours to understand our deen better...Jazakallah

Mashallah! Y'all did a great job in explaining such an important event in simple words. The ones who are new to Islam or are not muslims too can understand this clearly.

This message motivated me greatly
I'm a Shia Muslim from Sierra Leone,West Africa 🇸🇱

You pagans and your delusions,

Being a Muslim we all believe everything happens with as per Allah will....so first Khalifa Hazrat Abu Baker ra, and then second Khalifa Hazrat Umer ra, third Khalifa Hazrat Usman n forth Khalifa Hazrat Ali ra were n everything that happened in all those years were happened as per Allah will n Allah knows the best...May be there is a lesson for all the Muslims to come until the day of judgment to read the factual history with truth and learn the lesson...each Khalifa had a very important and unique role to play which all of them did and that too Allah Almighty will....
For me this argument or division amongst the muslims from those days might have have made some sense and whatever has happened in this history has a lesson for all of us but people who are still divided and debating about this issue is totally useless and they are wasting their time in a useless argument and some Muslims who dislike or even hate some Sahaba on the basis of those things which happened 1400years ago are just making it impossible for themselves to get into paradise...
There were thoseands of Muslims who embraced shahadut in those war and we are nobody to judge wo is right or wrong...Even the least pious of anyone from those days is millions of tes much pious then today's scholors from all school of thoughts or sects...May Allah grant them all the highest place in jannat and guide today's Muslims to be united rather ther debating the events from those days coming from multiple sources and many lies have been added over these 1400 years and anybody who dislikes any companion of Hazrat Muhammad PBUH and still believes he can enter jannat is totally lost and must ask Allah Almighty for forgiveness...May Allah Almighty guide us all and show the right path.....
And it's a totally useless debate about wat happened between those Sahabas, it was mostly political dispute for the sake of power and doesn't effect the teachings of Islam.

We are nobody to compare companions of Hazrat Muhammad PBUH?? And only Allah Almighty knows who has wat status infront...we love them and like them equally

How come some shias believe things which are just beyond a good Muslim??
And the way the tell lies about or some even abuse Companions of Holy Prophet Muhammed PBUH and still think that they can enter paradise is beyond my belief??
As a Muslim we must be united and to compare who is superior among the companions of Hazrat Muhammad PBUH is the most illogical thing to do??
They claim that they love Ali ra more then sunnis is just in their head and by doing so they down play and many of them even openly nauzubillah abuse other companions of hazrat Muhammed PBUH and they still believe that the can enter the paradise is just beyond my understanding.....May Allah guide them and show them the right path..Amen

علی ولی الله ♥️💌

The next big thing for Muslims is to get past the past and unearth, gather the lost literature and teachings of Ahlulbayt due to persecution and what not!
Everyone should come together with a scholarly and analytical mind and with the emphasis on freedom of decent and unharmful expression in one’s own space without forcing it on others - this open mindedness will eventually pave way to solutions and the right way as Islam is logical and ‘Let there be no compulsion in religion, for the truth stands out clearly from falsehood….(Quran-2:256)’, if you allow freedom of decent and unharmful expression in one’s own space without forcing on others!

Disobeying Allah swt In regards to Ghadeer and the Quranic verses Clearly says something about the sunni sect. They will twist everything to their Favor. Allah curses the liers and the hypocrites

Excellent video.👏

May Allah be pleased with you and your efforts! Wish you a blessed Aid al Ghadeer.

Thank yu very much

I'm Shia

great documentary. The root of Islam is Ghadeer

Ghadir Khumm

Linguistically:

Mawla has many meanings like sayyid, helper, someone you love and aid.

Mawla comes from the word Al walayah, not Al wilayah (Al waliyy) which means leadership. They’re 2 different words.

The proof that the word Mawla doesn’t mean khilafa from the Qur’an - Allah mentions an ayah with the word mawla, mentioning Allah, the believers and the angels:

‎فَاِنَّ اللّٰهَ هُوَ مَوۡلٰٮهُ وَجِبۡرِيۡلُ وَصَالِحُ الۡمُ
‎ؤۡمِنِيۡنَ ۚ وَالۡمَلٰٓـئِكَةُ بَعۡدَ ذٰلِكَ ظَهِيۡرٌ‏

then Allah is his supporter, and Jibra’īl (Gabriel) and righteous believers, and after all that, angels are his helpers.
(66:4)

According to Shi’a logic; Allah is using the word mawla (مَوۡلٰٮهُ) in this ayah, Allah is a khalifa over the prophet and THEN the angel Jibreel is also khalifa, and then the believers are also khalifas according to Shi’a argument which makes no sense. Therefore, it doesn’t mean leadership.

Context of Ghadir Khumm:

There was a disagreement over ghaneema (spoils of war) amount between Ali and buraydah ibn husayb, Buraydah disliked Ali for that and complained to the prophet, so the prophet backed Ali and reminded the people about Ali because he knew that later on people will make Takfeer on him and rebel against him I.E the Khawaarij.

At ghadir khumm, the Muslims were returning back to their homes and heading towards medina and the surrounding areas after Hajj. There was only a few hundreds or maybe thousands of Muslims.
If Ali becoming khalifa was so important, the prophet would of announced it in front of all the people at Hajj ,The Farewell Sermon ( خطبة الوداع, Khuṭbatu l-Widāʿ ), where there was around 100,000 Muslims from all over the world like Yemen, Iraq, Sham etc.




Nahjul balagha letter 6 to Muawiya 446:

"Verily, those who swore allegiance to Abu Bakr, `Umar and `Uthman have sworn allegiance to me on the same basis on which they swore allegiance to them. (On this basis) he who was present has no choice (to consider), and he who was absent has no right to reject; and consultation is confined to the muhajirun and the ansar. If they agree on an individual and take him to be Caliph it will be deemed to mean Allah's pleasure."

Ali himself didn’t know about being divinely appointed? Oh Shi’a why’s that? He confirms and acknowledges the Muhajireen and Ansaars decisions to appoint the Khalifa at the time of Abu Bakr and his own.

Ali refuses khilafa a year after Ghadir Khumm event (Bukhari), 24 years after (nahjul balagha):

The author of the book Nahj al-Balagha – a reliable source for the Shia, reports that Ali RadiaAllahu Anhu refused to be the Caliph after the martyrdom of Uthman when people gathered around him requesting him to assume the caliphate and besought them to accept their leadership.

“Leave me alone; go in search of somebody else….If you leave me alone I shall be just like you as an ordinary citizen of the Islamic State…As a matter of fact I like to guide you and advise you more than I would wish to rule over you.”

Source: Nahjul Balagha p 136, see also pg 366-367 and pg 322. See pg 263 the Nahjul Balagha published by Islamic Seminary Publication Translated by Askari Jafri.(Sermon 95.)


Hadith in Sahih Bukhari:

Narrated 'Abdullah bin 'Abbas:

'Ali bin Abu Talib came out of the house of the Prophet during his fatal ailment. The people asked ('Ali), "O Abu Hasan! How is the health of Allah's Apostle this morning?" 'Ali said, "This morning he is better, with the grace of Allah." Al-'Abbas held Ali by the hand and said, "Don't you see him (about to die)? By Allah, within three days you will be the slave of the stick (i.e., under the command of another ruler). By Allah, I think that Allah's Apostle will die from his present ailment, for I know the signs of death on the faces of the offspring of 'Abdul Muttalib. So let us go to Allah's Apostle to ask him who will take over the Caliphate. If the authority is given to us, we will know it, and if it is given to somebody else we will request him to recommend us to him. " 'Ali said, "By Allah! If we ask Allah's Apostle for the rulership and he refuses, then the people will never give it to us. Besides, I will never ask Allah's Apostle for it." (See Hadith No 728, Vol 5)

Source: Sahih Bukhari 6266

THEREFORE, Ali himself didn’t know he was even supposed to be KHALIFA but SHI’A say he was.

SubhanAllah! May Allah guide all Muslims on the path of Nabi Muhammad & Ahlulbayt Ameen !

This means the majority of Sunnis are misguided...

Excellent presentation .. aslam from Indiana USA

why its not mention in quran clearly if this is the one of the major factor in Islam?

What does mean Ghadeer

اللهم صل على محمد وعلى آل محمد 💌🤲❤🌹 thank you so much for this information and knowledge..

Great knowledge and wisdom to clarify the reason and autheticity that's very appreciative. You all mentioned open truth and reality!
MASHA ALLAH. Ghadeer e Khum event is real and real Momin knows it.

Mashalla Nare Haidari YaA Ali 🤲

Sunni narratives list no less than 70 times 'Ali was given special authority, but gives no naming of the Khulafah nor A'imah.
Some narratives say that the final sermon was during the farewell Hajj and Ghadeer was on the way to Hajj on the 25th of the 11th month.

Great video! Too many commercials.

MashaAllah 🤲🏻🤗