I Tried Every AI Coding Assistant

I Tried Every AI Coding Assistant

Conner Ardman

5 месяцев назад

660,360 Просмотров

Ссылки и html тэги не поддерживаются


Комментарии:

@ConnerArdman
@ConnerArdman - 23.11.2023 18:00

Correction on Sourcegraph Cody:
I wasn't fully using this one correctly. You can download an additional app and link it to your GitHub repository, and it does a much better job of understanding the repo. I'm not sure why the UX doesn't prompt you to do this from the start, but it does fix some of the problems in the video such as over-indexing on node modules. However with all that said, I honestly still wasn't able to get it to perform many tasks that were particularly useful, and the larger the repo I gave it, the less reliable the responses seemed to become. It could definitely be worth a shot in your projects to see if it is useful to you though! 😃

Ответить
@mazet5296
@mazet5296 - 01.01.2024 07:07

nice channel and content. i like how you direct ur videos!!

Ответить
@aosamai
@aosamai - 31.12.2023 16:38

you did a fantastic job in this comparison , thanks a lot for the video

Ответить
@kell7689
@kell7689 - 31.12.2023 06:07

I absolutely love Copilot

Ответить
@BruceOnder
@BruceOnder - 30.12.2023 21:26

Great roundup (except for Codium) but I think you should ask ChatGPT to help you define better tier lists in the future.😂

Ответить
@user-mn7nh6yn5y
@user-mn7nh6yn5y - 30.12.2023 06:31

For more complicated functions you need more detailed prompts. At the end of the day, it just saves you some typing time given enough context.

Ответить
@kuntrasha
@kuntrasha - 30.12.2023 04:28

A key difference between bard and chatgpt is bard is a better teacher. Chatgpts info is a touch better but it struggles to help u learn using hints and guiding and usually gives the full answer to you no matter have many times u tell it not too. Bard is really good with giving hints and directions and will listen to u if you tell it not to provide snippets.

Ответить
@88spaces
@88spaces - 30.12.2023 02:02

I had no idea there was a GitHub Copilot chat feature in VS 2022. I installed it and am already more productive. Thank you.

Ответить
@SomeRandomCanuck
@SomeRandomCanuck - 30.12.2023 01:19

No Jetbrains AI? Weak.

Ответить
@MisaNotMisa
@MisaNotMisa - 29.12.2023 22:10

I can confirm that Copilot is absolutely worth it for real life production code. It might not always come up with the best solutions specially for more custom/complex problems, but that's what you're being paid for as a developer. It's great as a smart autocompletion tool too.

But something amazing about Copilot (idk about the others as I haven't tried them) is how well it understands context. It uses your own code as a reference to write new code and is quite aware of the context where you're trying to put code.

I'm specially surprised when, from time to time, I plan to write a complex piece of code and it knows exactly what I was going to do. It saves a lot of time.

For an actual fair comparison I think all of these features would have to be tested on the other tools, with real life projects. As entertaining as the video is, it doesn't help much to know how good they are at writing a factorial function.

Ответить
@ridewarior2832
@ridewarior2832 - 29.12.2023 17:04

I literally haven’t seen your channel before but I gotta comment about how much I appreciate that your video just starts. There isn’t 3-5 minutes of just bs when the topic is literally explained in the title. THANK YOU!

Ответить
@andryshin5224
@andryshin5224 - 29.12.2023 06:09

hi do you know which bot that can code amibroker afl / tradingview with good accuracy?

Ответить
@LarsRyeJeppesen
@LarsRyeJeppesen - 28.12.2023 17:16

DuetAI was the best for me, jumped ship from CoPilot. It's based on Gemini.

Ответить
@bryanlee5522
@bryanlee5522 - 28.12.2023 07:36

ok i've been using copilot for months and have been very underwhelmed and feel confused why people love it so much. just now realized that it does more than autocomplete

Ответить
@ookami38
@ookami38 - 28.12.2023 00:30

It wasn't right.

Ответить
@im-essi
@im-essi - 27.12.2023 20:54

I wonder if one issue with the jsdoc comments there is your editor automatically inserting " * " for new lines; might confuse them (not that it should, but clearing that line I guess their suggestions would be more reasonable).

Ответить
@norbertferenczi4243
@norbertferenczi4243 - 27.12.2023 20:42

próbáltál egy hibás adatot beprogramozni mondjuk 0 értéke van a migrációnak:)

Ответить
@disgruntledtoons
@disgruntledtoons - 27.12.2023 19:53

The reason that AI makes mistakes like this is because of the two letters in the acronym, only the first one is correct.

Ответить
@daiadecadix
@daiadecadix - 27.12.2023 17:46

the kind of channel that is my regula subsccrption choice good job thank you happy noche vieja

Ответить
@mattjames4978
@mattjames4978 - 27.12.2023 07:11

Green is worst and red is best? You’re not a UI dev then!

Ответить
@stewiegriffin6503
@stewiegriffin6503 - 27.12.2023 04:42

dude, GPT 4.0 is God. Period.

Ответить
@bab4953
@bab4953 - 26.12.2023 00:46

what about phind?

Ответить
@thefirstuwu8874
@thefirstuwu8874 - 25.12.2023 15:35

But how do such tools perform in big project and not so leetcode problems?

Ответить
@bohdanmartynov
@bohdanmartynov - 24.12.2023 12:29

Too simple examples, I wonder how these AI will handle the complex logic of some application.

Ответить
@cloudstrife7083
@cloudstrife7083 - 23.12.2023 16:44

any of you is running VSCodium instead of VSCode on linux for privacy reasons ?

Ответить
@DimCervix
@DimCervix - 23.12.2023 13:44

Have you tried Jetbrains AI Assistant?

Ответить
@mickmickymick6927
@mickmickymick6927 - 23.12.2023 12:34

Do any work with Notepad++?

Ответить
@n3cr0ph4g1st
@n3cr0ph4g1st - 23.12.2023 03:28

Gotta try cursor dawg

Ответить
@fksllil4068
@fksllil4068 - 23.12.2023 00:33

Wait until he finds out about mixtral 8x7b

Ответить
@jesperholm5174
@jesperholm5174 - 22.12.2023 19:48

what about Phind?

Ответить
@jesuschrist1501
@jesuschrist1501 - 22.12.2023 06:36

the BIGGEST coding challenge that you didn't do and compare is... how well these ai's know how to implement api's and libraries. chatgpt can generate opengl code of a simple hello world on command, does any other assistant ai do that?

Ответить
@x0rld159
@x0rld159 - 21.12.2023 22:03

for cody in the first question it suggest the <=1 for the factorial function

Ответить
@eshnd.
@eshnd. - 21.12.2023 08:49

mixtral dolphin >>>

Ответить
@EkalabyaGhosh
@EkalabyaGhosh - 21.12.2023 04:42

Try out bard

Ответить
@JPNox
@JPNox - 21.12.2023 02:52

What do you think about Jetbrains AI?

Ответить
@bukanjamiel9825
@bukanjamiel9825 - 20.12.2023 10:58

Bard has the advantage of being able to access the internet. You can give him an API documentation and he'll make you a wrapper

Ответить
@circulartext
@circulartext - 20.12.2023 10:43

nice

Ответить
@OleksiiDuhnist
@OleksiiDuhnist - 20.12.2023 09:51

lol, where is codeuim?

Ответить
@ignacioniveiro5471
@ignacioniveiro5471 - 20.12.2023 06:04

How do you enable Code Whisperer autocompletion in VS code?

Ответить
@hanzofuma
@hanzofuma - 20.12.2023 03:26

The day when I will be able to open Firefox repository or LibreOffice repository in my editor and having an AI assistant explaining and helping me learn about the repo, which saves me months of reading and looking. I'll say that AI assistant a thing. Right now, they just copy and paste code. I'm hoping for the big thing in the near future.🙏

Ответить
@LSPpeepoSnow
@LSPpeepoSnow - 20.12.2023 00:54

I use Bing AI with high precision mode and the code it generates is really good, I must say much better than chat gpt itself although it is from gpt. The problem is it can only handle 30 conversations per chat. It also remembers previous topics better than Chat GPT.

Ответить
@LonersGuide
@LonersGuide - 20.12.2023 00:31

Video is 3 weeks old, so now obsolete.

Ответить
@backstabba
@backstabba - 19.12.2023 21:38

I use the same ones you are using except the documenting one (probably will at some point).

On rare occassions, I go with Bard.

I had an interesting case where ChatGPT and Bard disagreed both with Copilot about efficiency of a JS loop. Copilot was going with a more readable code and claimed it is also more efficient, but after running tests, I found out it is about %5 less efficient and personally did not find it readable.

Ответить
@RafaellLycan
@RafaellLycan - 19.12.2023 15:31

Hey Conner,

Do you mind sharing what software you used to record and add the camera effect (gradient border)?

Thanks

Ответить
@sharpfang
@sharpfang - 18.12.2023 23:00

How would you rate Phind on that list?

Ответить
@MuhammadArrabi
@MuhammadArrabi - 18.12.2023 22:43

great video. Would love to see your evaluation of Replit Ghostwriter

Ответить
@sindudinarbangunleksono2409
@sindudinarbangunleksono2409 - 18.12.2023 20:21

well as a college student, chatgpt is the only reason as to why i can make android app in 2 nights and make website manually with html css java php no framework in 1 week :v for learning case, chatgpt is superior because it is not a pure code but there are sometimes explanation.

Ответить
@merion297
@merion297 - 18.12.2023 19:13

Extremely useful test! Thanks! 🙏

Ответить