How Does an Editor Think and Feel?

waw

Sooooooo cool

This was so helpful! Thank you!

Incrível!!! 👏👏👏👏

My heart melts how beautiful Taylor and Tony's videos are ❤

As an editor, I can say with confidence that I feel soft

COME BACK!! <3

this was beautiful

I’ve been camera scanning for about 2 years now and it’s so cool to see other photographers workflow and how they use grow their tools.

I feel super weird most days.

i think a sense music is an essential part of editing

hi tony! youll never make a film. get an education and a career.

Thank you

As a Mexican editor I can say I absolutely hated working with the pink assholes. I was the ONLY brown editor in my department at Warners and pretty much EVERY boutique house. It was a great job but shitty people. What do the teach you in film school to hate people of color and that’s how I felt.

This was wonderful thank you!

Everyone asks when the editor will finish, but not how the editor feels 😢

Very nice edit! This video made me realise my main challenge in watching more 'serious' movies. I tend to focus on the plot and what's happening on a more logical level, rather than just surrender to what the scenes are making me feel. The comparison between the Star Wars and Antman scenes was a very good example.

Something needs to be said about your humility. So many filmmakers put the camera on them and talk and talk and talk about the new cable they just bought. You don't. And saying that you've been editing for 10 years and that you're "still not there" is very refreshing. We need fewer narcissists and more... editors?

Great vid mate! Yes, editing is not about Avid vs Resolve and whatever fascinating workflow you espouse, it’s about FEEL. 33 year veteran editor here. Note for non-editors: never tell an editor how to edit, tell the editor how you want the viewer to feel.

I have Walter Murch's book In The Blink of An Eye. In it he outlines a list of reasons to cut and what to sacrifice in order to decide your cut. The first thing you can change is 3-D space of action. The most important to retain is the emotion of the scene. There are six items on the list and I try to abide by them. It helped my editing a great deal.

Yeah, Ant Man is trash

You have to feel when to..
Brilliant.

Wow I never took editing seriously at the Oscars. Now it will be a category I look forward to seeing. Can’t believe I hadn’t seen this video sooner.

Question is: 🤔🤔 When editing a music video - how do you keep your cuts away from being on beat (as it's very inviting)- and create a separate pacing/ rhythm of cuts that's not on beat, yet, still feels good with the music?

There are few people that can teach you about editing as well, or as quickly. This could easily be the basis for a series on one of the streaming services. It enables film viewers to discover new ways to appreciate and understand film.

thank you!

I feel like for the Star Wars and Ant man part, the time of the shots fit with the character’s personality.

Why did this channel dry up? Did the author fall ill or expire? Based on the quality of the existing content, it's hard to imagine he ran out of things to say or new ideas about things already said. I hate unsolved mysteries. So unsatisfying. So tell me, he or she that knows. Wazzup?

thank you

I enjoyed every single second of this video, each detail is impeccable ¡Thank you!

Thumbnail?

I always wondered how exactly an editor knows when to cut, and this explains a lot. Thank you for this.

Just subbed for future viewing. Haven't watched a single video yet.

when to what?

:)

I learned so much from this video. I've been watching movies since I can remember, and I never thought about how emotion is conveyed by the cuts. It's like a whole new way to pick up on the purpose of a scene

4 seconds? Sometimes a single frame makes a difference to the tone of a cut.

Thank you Sir

guys help what is a hollywood edit plea se

Que brutalidad, he visto 2 videos de este canal y ya aprendi mas que en mi escuela de cine

It's 2023 and this channel is still the GOAT. Miss y'all, Taylor + Tony. Hope you're doing well!

How are you Tony? Just checking on you man..

You have to feel when to..... goosebumps

Why haven't you posted in last 6 years? Pls make more videos, I happen to come across this video just today and loved it

Scott wasn't really trying and I think his frame number shows that very well

What’s the name of the last film ?

Does anyone else feel like he misses the “when… to… [cut]” moment? Is it just me? He should have held it a little longer, IMO 😅