Комментарии:
Some notes—
Population of the Confederation: 142,000,000 [10th]
GDP: 4,402,000,000,000$ [4th]
GDP per Capita: 31,000$ [37th]
If the ottomans had an industrial revolution and political development maybe they would’ve had a chance and survived the war
ОтветитьActually, I think that if the ottomans hadn’t joined ww1 Russia wouldn’t have its civil war due to the straights being open and allied shipment being able to send guns and other weapons to bog down Germany
ОтветитьI did that video 1 day before you in my channel :D
ОтветитьGreat ending
ОтветитьIf the Ottomans didn't join, they would have fallen to revolutions first by Iraqis in Najaf, Basra and Baghdad later Syrian Peasants in the Syrian plains and Lebanon finally the Hashmites in Hejaz
Luristan place was wrong because that is Ahwaz and Jordan wouldn't exist it will probably be Syrian or Palestinian
The best mapper
ОтветитьSelahattin Demirtaş as a prime minister ??????????????????
Ответитьvery beautifully done . and by the way , where do you get these maps from Google ?
ОтветитьReturn the Ottoman glory
🇲🇷❤️🇹🇷☝️😭
mighty interesting scenario but how do the arabs get the manpower, weapons and expertise to launch their own independent nations without being quickly snuf out by the ottomans?
ОтветитьI am Palestinian-Syrian Arab and i dont know how i feel about this, I mean its not good but its much better than our world since no I*rael, Syria is more stable i guess and there is less war so one one hand its better for the levant and Iraq but on the other hand gulf states would never be rich because of constant war so we would never have Cities like Dubai, Abudhabi, Doha and Saudi in this timeline or I guess ''Hejaz'' would be a poor unstable country unlike in this time line with the Saudi Arabia who are rich, stable and also in this timeline its easier for Muslims to do Hajj since Mecca is in safe hands under the Saudis (Like them or not they did a great job in perserving the holy cities of Mecca and Medina) while in this timeline it would be much harder to go to either mecca or Medina plus these cities would be in a poor backwater country so I really dont know how to feel about this, I guess its slightly better but not great.
ОтветитьBrooo how did Selahattin Demirtaş become president?
ОтветитьWhat if Venice discovered America instead Spain?
ОтветитьWhat if Mughal Empire survive
ОтветитьThailand pls!!!
ОтветитьDo a remastered alternate history of the us
ОтветитьI don't get why the ottomans would have to fall into a Civil War this late or why they wouldn't win it, given that they woykd be supported by the west, but still the video was great and its a better ending for turkey that OTL
Ответитьwhat editing software do you use? since the animation is really smooth
ОтветитьAlways love a good LionHeart video!
ОтветитьSo What Happened To Atatürk In This Alternative Universe?
ОтветитьGreat war slide
ОтветитьThe Iraq movie is like an Italian flag
ОтветитьPera aí o iraq é a bandeira da Itália invertida?
ОтветитьHey,at least no Israel!
ОтветитьOttomans could have captured Crimea in 1918
ОтветитьBest timeline in some case: No partition of Middle East, No Arab-Israeli wars, No extremists groups, No 9/11, No war of Terror. But bad for Armenia their country dissapeared.
Ответитьottoman has sadam fusain as
general
Could you do a Serbian one, Hungarian, Greek, and possibly if Assyria became a thing after ww1 (choose the borders either from irl proposals or your own one)
ОтветитьI like that you are now showing internal conflicts inside of the topic country instead of giving them plot armor
Ответитьwhat if the confederate states of america won the civil war?
ОтветитьVery interesting concept, though I struggle to believe a few things:
1. The Ottomans would likely not be successful in their invasion of White Russia- Denikin's southern offensive would've leapt into action at that time, and considering the mild success that the Moscow had over the Soviets, the ottomans would stand little to no chance at an offensive over the Caucasus.
2. The Zionist movement, however weakened by the lack of government support, would still expand. Under the Ottomans, the Zionist movement has risen as the primary Jewish movement, outshining Bundism. It would grow exponentially, especially after World War 2. The region would however, likely still remain under a Muslim majority, though a significant Jewish minority. A flipped version of the current situation, if you will.
3. Decolonialization. With few exceptions, it is likely that without any "Iron Fisting", the ottomans would be forced to give up some authority to their minorities during the cold war. Autonomy to some, independence to others, you get the jist.
This is not a criticism, just a few points for thought. I like this video nonetheless. I especially compliment your animation, which is phenomenal.
What if the white army won the Russian civil war?
Ответитьgreat video and next nation russia
Ответитьcool video
ОтветитьNice video, shame there wasn't an ethnic map in the end
ОтветитьYes thanks for this video greetings from Turkiye!!! ❤️
ОтветитьWas it really the good ending though?
ОтветитьNice vid bro
ОтветитьPlease do Korean Empire too. 😊
ОтветитьGreat video love the lore
ОтветитьBeautiful! Thanks for doing that!
ОтветитьI wish you would give the north of syria to turkiye back :(
ОтветитьWhat if white Russians won the sivil war
Ответитьwhen you thought everything was going fine for "the sick man of europe.... sudden civil war
but yea, i liked how the ottomans eventually adopt liberal policies and exponential growth throughout the 20th century. in a way, they fill the spot of saddam. gg dude, this was great
Very unrealistic as The Ottoman Empire would probably go to absolute monarchy or the Rashidun system of the best islamic scholars voting for the most competent leader and would probably become more islamistic, the only reason turkey today is largely secularised is because of Ataturk but he never gained power here.
ОтветитьWhen did the genocides happen in this timeline? The young Turks?
Ответить