Assassin's Creed - What If Shay Never Betrayed The Assassins?

Also there should be a trilogy for almost every assassin because it’s not fair that Eliot gets 3 games and all of the better ones only get one. Not saying Ezio isn’t cool which he is. But still be a good idea.

I would love to see a what if Connor joined Haytham. Being a big AC3 guy I have always wondered what would have happened. Just a thought. I have so many others that I might send to Ubisoft and or Netflix to see if they would do an AC What If.

What if ezio's family was never killed.

Do a video where you rank and talk about all the AC dlc's

It would be a truly impressive change, but I think that if Shay had never become a Templar, there would have been many important changes, Connor would still be born because when Haytham meets Ziio and they fall in love, that happens shortly before when Shay was in the earthquake. Portugal, without Shay on the side of the Templars, Haytham's order would be weak and they would not be able to face the brotherhood of Achilles, but I feel that anyway at some point Haytham would face Achilles and as we saw in Rogue, which Achilles' life was saved by Shay, and by not being in this hypothetical fight, Haytham would mercilessly kill Achilles, leaving Shay as the new mentor of the American brotherhood and going for revenge and perhaps it would be possible to see a final fight between Shay now being Achilles' successor as grandmaster of the assassin order vs Haytham as grandmaster of the Templars. And in the event that Shay cannot defeat Haytham (because in this hypothesis he always remained an assassin and for obvious reasons he would not have Templar training) I would train Connor so that he, together with Shay, makes a final fight against Haytham in ac3 .

I truly believe whenever I think about this that Shay would always leave the order. Not join the templars or assassins but just to be independent of the politics of the situation.

I would kill for a game where Conner and Arno team up to hunt Shay. Since both Conner and Arno are both affected by Shay in one way or another and both are alive around the same time how they couldn’t figure out a way for them to team up is beyond me

What if Bayek's son never died?

Shay is the definition of “I’m him”

Well, Imagine if Ezio or Altair didn't exist. Madmen like Al Mualim or Borgias with extreme powers - that'd be unthinkable.

he never betrayed them the templars are also not the bad guys they want the same as the assassins just in another way haytham revealed that and we all know he isnt a bad guy even tho the templar did bad things im sure hes kinda right
shay basically just kept following his kredo

Anakin also had justification for what he did, the Jedi Order was as corrupt as Aquilies' brotherhood

The only tenet of the Creed Shay broke is "do not compromise the brotherhood" and at that point, it wasn't the brotherhood

Are you serious In one video you said achillies was wrong he should listen Shay
And now you are saying Shay betrayed Assassins
Wow

Honestly, part of me wishes they explored the sun actually wiping most of civilization out. At least as a spin-off game.

what a good sir! #22

i have a what if that will change ac 1 to mirage what if juno never betrayed the other 2
boommmmmmmmmm

Shay and Haytham were way better than Achilles.
Achilles left them with no option other than quitting the brotherhood.
Achilles shall never be forgotten or forgiven for his decisions.

May the father of understanding guide us

For another what if, you should do what if Ezio killed Rodrigo Borgia in the end of Assassin’s Creed 2.

If shay stayed At the brotherhood AC3 would be a story about a full fledged war between assassin and templar to take control of the American revolution instead of Connot single handedly rampaging the templar


Here more cool what ifs

What If Altair never demoted
What if Ezio father and brother survived
What if Haytham was raised by Edward
What if Edward joined the Torres Templar
What if Shay never killed Arno dad (Indirect sequel of this what if)
What if The Frye Twins betrayed each other
What if Bayek son never been killed
What If Kassandra and Alexios was fraternal twins like the Frye twins
What if Eivor was Loki incarnation and Basim was Odin incarnation

What if Shao jun meet Naoi Fujubayashi and Yasuke in AC red

Can u pls do an assassins and templar free for all battl who would win.( not who is a better assassin or templar but who would be first second and third in an assassins and templars free for all anyone can fight anyone )

If Shay didn't kill Arno father then the story would mostly the same in Unity. Romeo x Juliet type. Maybe Arno and Elise would still fall in love but when they're fighting each other.

What if Conner met Arno?


What if Haytham was an assassin?


What if Ezio never left to see Masyaf?


What if Desmond never died?


What if Edward was a Templar?


What if Arno wasn’t a simp?

Lazerzz already did a video on this subject, did you see it

What if Arno was sent on a mission to England and he met conor but mistakenly he found a lead on shy Patrick that he is still alive on some low profile i always wanted that battle but it Will never happen

Here is a what if scenario, since I did a “canon” playthrough of Odyssey, but you know how Kassandra’s family are considered a curse, and that anyone with Leonidas’s DNA will cause the world to suffer or something along the lines? What if the Cult of Kosmos never bothered the King nor his descendants, OR what if they never kidnapped infant Alexios but guaranteed his death?

Basic bitch what if

What if Altair lost against his master ? In the final battle.

What if khemu didn't die at the beggining of origins or what if eivor became a hidden one just some ideas

What if Shay stayed in the colonies and Haytham went to look for the manuscript

What if Desmond never died though?

If Shay didn't kill Charles Dorian then Arno would probably grow up with the teaching of the Creed and have an appreciation for the Assassins, fighting for them rather then using them as a way to get his revenge

What if the roles were reversed and the Borgia were assassins and the alditores were templars

What if Arno delievered the letter to Elise's father?

What if Edward continued to serve/help the templars for the money..? 🤔

Is this going to be a full Series?

You should retitle this to “What if the Assassin’s never betrayed Shay”

What if Odyssey was actually an AC game?🧐

What would happen if Altair destroyed the apple like he said he would?

Imagine the ULTIMATE DUO in the distance on a small mountain peak shouting from the top of their lungs.

- I MAKE MY OWN LUCK!
- GIVE ME LEE!

Do a stealth only video on ghost of tsushima

Idea: assassin's creed makes a game were they see what would happen in a bunch of what ifs such as what if shay didn't betray the brotherhood? what if Connors village didn't burn? What if Arnos father didnt died? What I'd assassin's creed vallhalla didn't exist?

I'd imagine a Homestead mission series with Shay and bonding system with other members? That would be cool

I think you should start making ac what ifs

What if Edward didn't join the assassin's after ac 4 and went his way to make more money

Next has to be this or I retire. “What if Ezio’s Family were never killed?”