kpop idols with the worst live vocals #shorts #kpop

Should I make a part 2?

Maybe its beacause they have to do the mv shootimg,pre shooting,pre recording /singging ,recod for singging ,having to dance mostly every week, dealing with Mistreatment, suicide, slave labor contracts, grueling training schedules, “no dating” clauses, sexual assault, and sexualization of minors
Having to go to the concerts ,award show etc , and STILL they give theyre best

Shuhua is literally so nice sometimes they get out of tune I understand it's not like they are always bad live Sakura ok it's ok I realise too but shuhua no no no😅

Without bts and blackpink this list is so incomplete.
Every member sucks 😂

No hate whatsovever but Jimin's clip was hard to watch.Hybe should start focusing on everything. not only dance/sp or rap.I know Jimin is talented but not everybody is an all rounder! But he needs proper training

It’s not that Jimin is a bad vocalist, he’s just had lots of high notes in the ot7 music which probably strained his voice and makes it harder to sing without any high notes. From his debut they really only gave him high notes to sing instead of just lines or some vocalizing like they do with Jungkook or Taehyung. Jimin’s voice is still really good but sometimes it can be unstable but they can’t just let Jimin sing without vocal training because think about having to sing without having any experience or at least a vocal coach but when Jimin does go on stage he does sound really

So emabarrassing

Yikes

People in the comments is just being rude , ik their not that good but you dont have to be so damn rude 😭

For people bitching about people making excuses, here's a real legit one that explains a huge issue in KPOP's vocals as a whole.

SO Sakura there, If I remember correctly she was on Produce101, well I remember a moment during "vocal training" where (I believe it was sakura) couldn't hit the right note as it was too high, The VOCAL TEACHER just told her to push through it.
This was also something I saw on the Unit, when a idol had hurt their voice while practicing to the point he was suffering with Vocal cord nodules the VOCAL TEACHER said "I have them too, and all my friends have them," he would then go on to tell the idol to rest their voice for today and sing later live.

Now with that knowledge, think about them pushing and straining their voices day after day with no rest for them or their vocal cords.

and with boy groups?! forget about it! they are constantly forced to sing outside of their vocal range. and if they too are being told to "just push through it" that explains some shit.

Just go and listen jimin vocals in magic shop. ..:)

Sakura and Shuhua asked for fewer lines because they weren't confident with their vocals, and Shuhua wasn't perfect with her Korean. Also, in that clip of Sakura it kinda sounds edited. Also calling Shuhua just a visual is rude. Shes talented in her own ways but she just lacks in vocal stability. (No hate to these idols!!!!!)

i love sakura , shes been one of my ult biases since iz*one but her singing really isnt that good lol.

Jimin vocal are best 💜

I understand Shuhua she asked for less lines in mv's but she's not just a visual!

jimin sing live like crazy so good he us human what a big deal

Kkura looks like shes about cry

Bruh, its crazy how people only bring up the mgas 2018 and like crazy encore stage to criticize Jimin.

imagine 10years idol sound like chicken

le sserafim KAZUHA OML (i love her but her vocals)..

why is sakura a singer if she can't even sing?

What's crazy to me is Jimin actually sounds fine but people think he's out of tune??

This vid shouldnt exist. So rude.

As you can see haters Jimin couldn't here his voice properly because he was fixing his earpiece❤

Jimin’s vocals in my opinion are great

Shuhua definitely tone deaf lol 😂

Sakura and Jimin one is so embarrassing. They have been in the industry for so long with the most experience 💀☠

honestly jimin just needs a good vocal coach and he'll be set. I'm army and as much as I love jimin's singing, he has his very noticeably weak moments. I just don't think ppl should keep using that one encore stage to say he's a bad singer. they aren't even supposed to be that good or serious anyway

starting song?

Okay but shuhuas comments was so mean for no reason like that's just pure hating

Sakura never complains about her lines, in fact in ‘The World is My Oyster’ she said herself she doesn’t want many lines. This is just sad, it’s not even her fault anymore and fans are hurting her feelings. HYBE needs to help Sakura with her voice. The fact that fans in this video that said these won’t ever even be close to what the idols are right now. They are playing with them like dolls. We know that these idols have unstable vocals, you don’t need to tell us. These fans are disgusting. Criticising can help sometimes but not when you’re literally commenting on something without thinking twice. Would you say that to their face? Exactly. Idols do have talents and some don’t. You shouldn’t hate on them for that, it’s not even their fault. Like I said, some K-pop fans are really pathetic while they hate on idols for having an unstable voice or anything and then they can’t even sing a single note. You would be dead saying this to any idol. Be glad you are online.

I am a Jimin Stan and he has done many times good live vocal performances, he many times also had voice cracks too, well that's because he wasn't trained to be a vocalist and he admits that but I am not trying to defend him. If he was given proper training and help then he might have show us some better vocals and actually that day he was pretty worn out so that is fine. He always delivers us powerful dances, raps and vocals so once is not a big deal and those who are saying that he had been a musician for ten years, dude voice doesn't become immune to voice cracks, sore throats and tonsils after ten years. He improves himself daily so if we force him on his mistake one time he may doubt himself. So I guess instead on hating them let's help them to get better. And he has always deliver powerful vocals, live or not, go watch his old songs if you don't believe me. He always ates his performance with godly dance, addictive raps and beautiful vocals. Overall he is a great singer so we should keep helping him and those who are saying he sounds like a radio, it's pretty hard to be an idol so it is better not to go too hard on them and of course it is their job and Jimin is fulfilling his job amazingly. So yeah, don't hate. Jimin is somewhat of a unstable vocalist not bad, needs some training that's it. I ain't defending him AND I TOTALLY BELIEVE THAT HE NEEDS TRAINING!

The fact armies are actually defending Jimin who is the lead Vocalist of the group is illogical and insane.
None of them in the video sang good tbh

Im sorry, even I can't defend Shuhua as a nevie for her singing. She can just be an idol, and not a singer.

I know this isnt about ATEEZ but i will still use this opportunity to promote my boys. They never sing off key. Like NEVER, check them out if u haven't

Is this real? Wow!

So you’re just gonna top talk absolute crap about idols and then justify what you said by saying “according to the netizens??? that’s just not right

You all are literally so urghh. Judging there whole existence based on one video.

Sakura is literally crying

Ikr brooo..😂😢



SIKE WDYM?!

i’m in love with Shuha’s voice😍

It’s one thing to sing off key while messing around on stage, laughing, having a good time, etc. It’s another thing to be standing still, doing nothing, and singing off key 💀 They are musicians. They should be able to carry a tune AT MINIMUM. You don’t have to do crazy notes or have an insane range to be a great singer. These guys just lack basic technique and I’m shocked. Especially for Jimin. He shouldn’t be that inconsistent when he’s been in the industry for like a decade.

No offense they really need to work on their vocals, especially kpop idols under hybe

It really isn't funny you have no right to hate on an idle even if they can't sing well

I love most of their idols and artist at hype but you definite can tell that they prioritize appearance than vocal talent.

Jimins earpiece wasn’t working that’s why you can see him touching and tapping it (it was said by a staff member) and bts and 2/3 gen idols have never taken those encore’s seriously so he probably didn’t feel the need to stress over the malfunction

Jimin was shy on that day cause he was alone he always has good vocals when performing with his members. So don't say it's the worst😕