EDM Producer VS POP Producer (EPIC BATTLE feat. Alex Rome)

Ayyyyy was an absolute pleasure being part of a video with you. Still thinking about that piano medley at the end of your piece which was beautiful. Thanks everyone for your positivity in the comments too 🤙🤙

It isn't about... The Producers.

Alex is clearly the winner....

Notice how when they both are listening to the vocal before the challenge starts, they nod their head to the tempo in synchronization. And there’s no drums or anything. As a music producer you start to do these things without thinking. It’s honestly amazing.

🎩

Feels like you rushed the listen-through of the 2nd track... whats up with that?

Can I say it was a tie? lol. I loved the vocal chops and the edm vibe from Alex but the ending of Nathans was spot on! It's almost like their songs need to be mashed together.

Both of u guys did an amazing job! But I would go with urs @nathonjameslarsen by a small margin because of the extra little layer of harmony creativity. @alexrome was great and the vocal chops were awesome. But his harmony was more standard than urs.

Where can we get the vocal stem for this project? I’d love to take a stab at this vocal myself and come up with something that’s a mix of the two versions.

I feel like I could do like a house version with ur harmony and a few more chord inversions, add some vocal harmony in places and do some interesting vocal chops.

are u into mixing it up with a saxophone player? Check my channel, or just ask me to go over one of your songs!

If u know someone else who is interested, same offer applies ;)

Both did great work

You and Alex are genius. I respect you 2 guys from my ❤

I'm EDM fans I like it both but it depends on my mood sometimes pop sometimes edm❤❤ from India

Alex

Alex wins for the first 85% of the song. Nathan nearly takes the learn with that dreamy ending and piano composition.

but why ableton ):

Definitely should do anther pop vs edm

If I'm the producer, I think I'll let it be a slap house track.

actually ı am edm producer but i like this pop arangement why ı dont know i think because thats drumkits and vocal chops place perfect.

both made absolutely BANGERS and it is a tough choice to choose one but i think alex took the dub... but nathan did an amazing job as well

Nathan's piano and far-away verb vocals seemed to have stolen the show. But I'll add Alex's passion for EDM music helps my own confidence.

EDM

:D

Both of the music is pretty good with its own uniqueness. But I like alex a little bit better because of the drop. The ending with nathans music is 🔥 its so good. Imagine if they combined the versions it will be the most lit music ever

EDM is bullshit

Alex's was better organized and he narrated his process better.

Both were nice but at the end Alex won in my opinion. And i am a pop guy.

Both of them

It may be me being bias but I liked Alex's more to me it seemed more balanced and in my mind music production is just like painting if you add to much of one thing it drowns out the rest of your hard work.

I am bias as i follow alex and i really dont like pop music but i actually really liked your rendition! ❤

gg

No importa cuantas veces vea este video siempre termino enamorandome nuevamente de producir música. Gracias por compartirlo. Saludos

Dude I listened to both twice , and I like both but honestly can’t decide who won. I think you both won… 😉

You guys should work together, you can make some good futuristic track!

Alex should buy himself flowers lol

Nathan's drop is weak af 😂

wow two equally gorgeous productions

Do a vid on arpeggios pls . Im a Rome fan but you did a better job on this track

Idk what to say, really🤔. Totally different vibe!!! Both 🔥🔥. I'd say it's a tie!

Wow you both did awesome job🎉

I don`t understand one thing Nathan`s melody and vocal sounds together like stuck together but Alex`s track sounds a bit interesting like melody and acapella is harmonic but like 2 different layer. Is the problem is about mixing or mastering or what ?

recently discovered Alex's channel (amazing rendition) and Nathan's rendition blew me away great ethereal quality that had that little bit extra but both efforts were solid 😎👍🏻 and subbed! 😁

Alex's was soo dopee...
N Nathan's was soo dreamyy... ❤

both are amazing

where do i can find the song? i mean, dont want to download this video audio

Man i can't pick a side you guys were both awesome. Great production. Can you guys provide the types of musical software used. Great work.
The Melody, and arrangements of both tracks were great.
I have a challenge i would like request, what if you both mixed your EDM and POP production what would you get out. It would be great to hear what that would sound like.

if it's me as an edm prdcr i ll make a deep house song

both amazing buttt EDM uffffffff

Alex