Tier List Andy: Madoka Magica. Best Magic Girl Waifu?

Pretty good list

Madoka is clearly the best waifu

Great tier list! 😊
Btw here is my enjoyment tier list:

1st: Homura
S: Madoka, Sayaka, Kyouko
A: Mami, Moemura, Madoka's mom, Akumura
B: Madoka's brother, Madokami, Teacher
C: Hitomi, Kyubey, Nagisa, Madoka's dad
Eww: Kyosuke


And my waifu tier list:
1st: Madoka
S: Madokami, Mami, Akumura
A: Moemura, Madoka's mom, Nagisa
B: Hitomi, Kyouko, Sayaka, Homura
C: Madoka's dad, Teacher, Madoka's brother
Eww: Kyosuke, Kyubey

i still find it funny that nobody asks any questions as to why homura is on the list 3 times.

HOMURA WOULD DO ANYTHING FOR THE ONE SHE LOVES THERE IS SO WAY PLEASE BE SO FR 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭

sayaka at the highest tier is so based but nobody ever appreciates her 💀 absolute W placement, shes easily my fav for a reason

MadoHomu team assemble!

Really, putting my girl Godoka down like that despite her gigachad outplay of Kyubey xD

Sayaka is my favorite character

sayaka best character? glad to see another man w taste 😍

I think it's a bit limited to see Homura as a "wall" or "flat" character, when you can see over the course of the anime that she is actively repressing her abundant emotions to devote herself to her task, keep her soul gem from darkening, not reveal too much information (her main advantage over everyone) and to make sure Mami doesn't start Dexter-ing magical girls again. I see the more emotional and open Homura from later episodes and Rebellion when she is alone with Madoka as a more accurate portayal of how she would be with a partner. What would bump her down the list for me is it feels like she couldn't truly love anyone as much as Madoka. I think to rate her accurately, you'd have to say: * this ranking is if you ARE Madoka.

I think Kyouko is a fabulous choice. Mami not so much. Just think about trying to go to sleep next to her when you know how crazy she can go in a world almost tailor-made to drive her insane. I'd never be able to trust her with my back, even though I can't turn into a witch, I'd never be able to take it easy around her despite the tea and cake. Sayaka had much more of an excuse, her soul gem was damn near black before she went crazy enough to hurt anyone. Homura, too, it took around 99 timelines of crying over dead Madokas, years of separation anxiety, turning into a demi-witch (a state that she maintained for a ridiculous amount of time before turning into a real witch), being told by Madoka "I'd never want to go far away and leave my friends" (which Homura took as her real feelings about becoming a god) and turning into a real witch to finally break and rebel against Madokami (and even then it was to restore Madoka's existence). I really respect the shit out of her strength.

Also, I can't forgive Kyouske for being the oblivious harem protagonist. Anybody with a brain should have seen that Sayaka was into him. I blame him for Sayaka's fall more than Hitomi. He's trash tier for me.

Earlier, you said Kyubey shouldn't have granted Madoka's wish, but I seriously doubt he had a choice. If he could have stopped it, he would have. Earlier in the anime, Kyubey said "suggesting wishes is against the rules," so apparently, Kyubeys have rules about how they are allowed to deal with humans. It makes sense, then, that they made the wish-granting mechanic something that Kyubeys can't refuse on the spot.

Finally someone who understand that Sayaka is best girl. That is so rare.

''Waifu'' bro they are 14

You should start on the Monogatari series lol

Kyoko and sayaka should not be this high

Solid lists! I personally would have put Homura a bit higher, for me Homura and Sayaka are my favorite characters. For most of the show, Madoka is just not as compelling as the other main characters I think. I also think that Sayaka and Kyouko have the best duo dynamic! That ending song and image of Ep 9 was brutal and beautiful...

Idle question: have you seen Fate/Zero? It's one of my favorite animes (I'm a Fate fan in general), in the same tier as Madoka Magica for me. It is written by the same author as Madoka Magica, Gen Urobochi. It has like 25 episodes, great watch in my opinion.

If you like to read manga too I recommend 2 of Madoka magica:

-the different story (that show the story “before the main series” between mami and kyouko)(this one feel likely a prequel to the serie I recommend it to you because you liked the good side of kyouko)

-wraith arc (that show the story between the end of the series and rebellion)(this one is a sequel for the serie and a prequel for rebellion, I recommend this to you because you like rebellion)

In the scene of the opening one of the 2 Madoka has the long hair and the close eyes (we can’t see if they are glowing yellow) is possible that she is the god version of her

Some correct terminology
Madokami = God Madoka
Kuumura = cool Homura
Moemura = glasses Homura
Akumura = demon Homura

Yeah for me homura is just the best character of all of them and she's pretty much the main character of the show haha.

Also im so happy to see sayaka and kyoko in best man.
Those 2 got so much hate over the years.

And back in the day mami was concidered the joke of the serie. I swear all i saw was head joke.

Sakura Kyouko♥️

Solid tier lists. Although Homucifer's position on the second one probably raises the most questions since she's literally a usual Homura but with maxed out toxicity and egoism stats to the point of becoming a local Satan.

Also, Madoka's Mom is clearly S tier smh.

Pls also react to the concept movie. It's really cool and has a killer song. Even by madoka standards

If you have time, give a chance to Madoka Magica the Different Story, it answers some interesting questions about Kyouko and Mami, as they are this spin-off protagonists, you would like it for sure.