Can Arabic, Persian and Turkish Speakers Understand Each Other? (Middle Eastern Countries)

Can Arabic, Persian and Turkish Speakers Understand Each Other? (Middle Eastern Countries)

World Friends

1 год назад

162,635 Просмотров

Ссылки и html тэги не поддерживаются


Комментарии:

catnug ratya
catnug ratya - 16.09.2023 00:50

there are no relation with Turkey and other these countries. may be half of Iran. others ara Arabic. Turks do not like arabics.

Ответить
KTG GTK
KTG GTK - 11.09.2023 14:08

None of these three languages are even remotely close to one another! Arabic is a Semitic language, Turkish is a central Asian language and Persian is an indo-European language!
The reason we think that they are related is because Iran and Turkey are geographically very close to Arabic speaking counties and ofcourse they are predominantly Muslim just like most Arabs are. Moreover, Iranian uses Arabic letters and Turkish has lots of borrowed Arabic words; otherwise, no connection whatsoever😂😂😂😂
In a way I felt sorry for the Turkish and Persian girls because their only understanding of Arabic would have been a few words here and there! I think they should have been replaced with other semantic language speakers such as Amharic or even Maltese!

Ответить
Pero Cigla
Pero Cigla - 10.09.2023 15:29

Man, this is fake, none of them is covered. Are they even from those countries? Especially Saudi Arabia, she even has a piercing.

Ответить
Layla.
Layla. - 10.09.2023 01:13

عسولتي لينا😊💕💕💕

Ответить
a
a - 09.09.2023 15:20

🇹🇷 Turkey is not a Middle Eastern country, it is a Eurasian country. stop making a fuss

Ответить
Yağmur Deniz
Yağmur Deniz - 09.09.2023 14:32

As a Turkish, I can easily say this video series (mena region that we are not part of this culture or region) are not entertaining to watch for Turkish people. Please put us a different video. @worldfriends77

Ответить
Arabi DIMA and whatever :p
Arabi DIMA and whatever :p - 09.09.2023 04:24

Not one wearing islamic clothing… just language 😅

Ответить
Weaj 🇸🇦
Weaj 🇸🇦 - 08.09.2023 14:14

The title says middle Eastern languages, Persians understood the title and didn’t have a problem Turks i think don’t understand english so they be crying in the comments saying Turkish is not in the same family as Arabic meanwhile Persian is in a different family too not only Turkish here but Persians didn’t say anything because they understood the title. The idea of the video is about Middle Easters languages; Arabic Persian and Turkish not Semitic languages

Ответить
바다🌊
바다🌊 - 08.09.2023 04:45

Why turkish people dont know Arabic they are also muslim and have quran!؟

Ответить
Selçuk Tufan
Selçuk Tufan - 07.09.2023 17:39

Turkish is not same with arabic. I dont understand why turkish girl is there?

Ответить
Puresinx🖤
Puresinx🖤 - 07.09.2023 13:42

Do Arabic and Hebrew.

Ответить
iliass iliass
iliass iliass - 06.09.2023 18:01

the Moroccan lady's IG pls??

Ответить
The Saudi
The Saudi - 05.09.2023 21:36

The Moroccan lady must be an actress or someone who works in fashion :)

Ответить
ehsan Jahani
ehsan Jahani - 04.09.2023 16:51

Fateme why you dont say dorod

Ответить
HANA
HANA - 02.09.2023 21:22

Im turkish and i didnt understand what they saying

Ответить
Ame__abouk
Ame__abouk - 02.09.2023 16:11

Btw the Tunisian girl is actually not talking Tunisian 🙂 she tried to make things easier

Ответить
Freya Cevik
Freya Cevik - 02.09.2023 13:37

Turks and persians are not Arab and these 2 girls feel like stranger in here; i can see…

Ответить
A.MARWANE
A.MARWANE - 02.09.2023 07:33

المغربية تيتييييييززة 😂😂❤❤❤❤🇲🇦

Ответить
Pisi sandy
Pisi sandy - 01.09.2023 11:02

Please make more videos with iranian❤

Ответить
Masid
Masid - 01.09.2023 02:16

Please compare Iranian with other Indo-European languages, such as Afkhani, Tajik, Indian, Pakistani, Farsi, a branch of the Aryan language, it has nothing to do with Arabic.

Ответить
Lamiae 🌼
Lamiae 🌼 - 31.08.2023 18:42

The Lebanese lady is so elegant and gorgeous

Ответить
öyle işte
öyle işte - 31.08.2023 16:54

Türk kızın İngilizcesi diğerlerine göre yetersiz

Ответить
mina
mina - 31.08.2023 16:26

deli misiniz ab siz turkoye ne alaka burda ya

Ответить
heyes
heyes - 31.08.2023 13:58

As a Turk I would like to see a video with people from Turkic countries like Azerbaijan, Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Uzbekistan and Turkmenistan

Ответить
sar
sar - 30.08.2023 17:26

morocco and tunisia are not in the middle east 🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️

Ответить
Bellasie
Bellasie - 30.08.2023 07:55

It's totally fascinating! In Paris, France we have an Oriental Languages Institute (university) called INALCO that teaches all of these languages, and they started out several centuries ago by teaching Persian, Turkish and Arabic to Louis XIV's ministers, before becoming a renown school nearly 300 years ago. Bachelor degree students in Turkish can take up other Turkic languages (such as Turkmen, Uzbek, Yakut, Tatar, Kazakh, etc.) and most dialects of Arabic are also taught. Oh, and of course they teach Korean, too! Look it up, it's unique in the world!

Ответить
Gon XHunter
Gon XHunter - 30.08.2023 03:34

srry won't watch it, Algeria is excluded 😡

Ответить
Yüsra07
Yüsra07 - 30.08.2023 00:09

bu insanlar bizi araplarla kıyaslıyorlarda araplardan daha köklü tarihe ve zamanında daha fazla coğrafyaya sahip olduğumuzu unutuyorlar.

Ответить
Call Me Bodhisattva
Call Me Bodhisattva - 29.08.2023 21:06

Super cool idea! Wish the audio was better and wish the women were better labeled for their countries throughout the video.

Ответить
Yekta M. Hırvatoğlu
Yekta M. Hırvatoğlu - 29.08.2023 12:32

Maybe we are bit cold blooded according to Arabs and Persians but I really like cute Yemeni girl. She is so warm and pretty 🤩 greetings from 🇹🇷

Ответить
S B
S B - 29.08.2023 07:23

Lebanese representation! 🥰💕💕💕

Ответить
Hacı Gandalf
Hacı Gandalf - 29.08.2023 02:20

Turkish, also known as Türkçe, is a language with a rich history that has evolved over time. Contrary to the common misconception, Turkish is not derived from Arabic. It belongs to the Turkic language family, which is completely distinct from the Semitic language family to which Arabic belongs.

Turkish has its origins in Central Asia and has been influenced by various languages throughout its development. The earliest form of Turkish, known as Old Turkic, was spoken by the Göktürks and other Turkic tribes in the 6th to 8th centuries. Over time, Turkish absorbed vocabulary from languages like Persian, Arabic, French, Italian, and English due to historical interactions and trade.

However, the core structure of Turkish, its grammar, and most of its vocabulary are rooted in the Turkic language family. Turkish underwent significant linguistic reforms under the guidance of Mustafa Kemal Atatürk, the founder of modern Turkey, to replace the Arabic script with the Latin alphabet and to simplify the language by removing Arabic and Persian loanwords.

In summary, Turkish is a member of the Turkic language family, and its historical roots and linguistic structure are distinct from Arabic. It has been shaped by various cultural influences, but its core identity remains rooted in the Turkic linguistic tradition

Ответить
Twisted
Twisted - 28.08.2023 14:03

Turkish is not one of the arabic language there is something like this when Turks werent meet with islam Persian people came and teach us islam so there is so many persian words in Turkish because of Ottoman Empire. Turkish is altaic language so its easy for Japanese,Korean,Mongolic,Tungusic and Turkic people(🇹🇷🇦🇿🇰🇿🇹🇲🇰🇬🇺🇿...)

Ответить
ByAvareSir
ByAvareSir - 27.08.2023 22:32

It's disrespectful and ridiculous that Turkey and Iran are in this video. Especially Türkiye is far from middle eastern culture.

Ответить
g
g - 27.08.2023 17:54

Turkey has no place for this group. Turkey is a Eurasian country. Not middle eastern! Dislike👎👎👎

Ответить
Aybuke
Aybuke - 27.08.2023 16:47

such a weird comparison that strengthens the wrong general thought: "turkish people speaks arabic". of course turkish people do share a lot of words as a result of living together for years in south east but it doesn't change the fact that turkish and arabic are completely different languages. in turkish there are lots of french words as well but it doesn't mean that turkish people can understand french. turkish should've been in a video with other turkic countries

Ответить
Fateme A
Fateme A - 27.08.2023 00:17

There are many old and middle persian words in arabic language that arabs calling it arabic word just like our scientists that they easily calling them arabic scientists
idk if they suffer from the lack of education or there are another reason

Ответить
Kemal
Kemal - 26.08.2023 06:23

Either Turkish and Persian are different language groups so it is unnecessary to complare that languages with Arabic dialects

Ответить
DoYouWant Thetotalwar
DoYouWant Thetotalwar - 25.08.2023 22:42

Three different language families which originated in totally different and unrelated parts of the world, came to occupy the same region in the last millenia. Long story short: No, they don't, except perhaps for the loanwords in the last thousand years.

Ответить
Cost
Cost - 25.08.2023 14:03

what's this? joke? what is turkish doing here? we may be in the middle east geographically, but our language and culture are of central asian origin. I didn't understand anything that was said here.

Ответить
Sherlock Holmes
Sherlock Holmes - 24.08.2023 16:36

Turkish is a very different language from Arabic. Its only connection with Arabic was under the influence of Islam in the past, the works were influenced by Arabic (only courtiers, because at that time the wealthy class and courtiers were interested in literature. The people were doing folk literature). For this reason, some Arabic and Persian words entered Turkish. Thanks to Atatürk in 1928, Turkish was simplified. Under the influence of Islam in the Ottoman period, Turkish separated from the root Turkish alphabet and switched to the Arabic alphabet. Atatürk changed this in 1928 and brought the Latin alphabet. In these years, English words have been added and are being added. If a video is to be made with this logic, the English accented video must also be in Turkish.

I want to add something extra. Here, Turkish is reflected as if it were an Arab country. We Turks are also very uncomfortable with this. For years, the foreign press, unfortunately, misrepresented the Turks. Turks come from Central Asia and have no kinship with Arabs. It's not that we don't like Arabs here. After all, we are Turks and we want to be known as Turks. I think there should be another video about Turks and Turkish nations should participate.

Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Uzbekistan, Turkmenistan, Turkey, Azerbaijan and Iran are at the forefront of the countries where Turkic peoples live intensely. People of Turkish origin, who are citizens of the autonomous republic or in a minority position, also live in Iraq, China (East Turkestan), Russia, the Balkans and various other European countries. (I got this article from Wikipedia)

I used Google translate while writing the text. Sorry if there are minor mistakes.

Ответить
quo vadis
quo vadis - 23.08.2023 09:28

In the secular Turkish republic founded by Mustafa Kemal Atatürk in 1923, women were given the right to vote and be elected in the 1930s!!! The whole world is watching and knows how women in the Islamic Republic of Iran and Saudi Arabia are subjected to what laws in the country! So why did you put Turkey here? This is impossible to understand! Even the former Iranian Shah Reza Pahlavi came to Turkey by train and was Atatürk's guest for 3 weeks in order to see Atatürk's revolutions closely! The shah of the period implemented these revolutions in his own country. At that time, Saudi Arabia was not even a state! Therefore, the Republic of Türkiye cannot have a place here!!! The Turkish-Persian cultural connection with Iran has existed since the Seljuk conquest of Iran, and Ancient Persian cultural values ​​are important. But even in Saudi Arabia, we have never had a religious understanding! First of all, I would like to remind the Turkish youth here!!

Ответить
ayman sendi
ayman sendi - 23.08.2023 03:29

As Kurdish i confirm Turks are Arabs

Ответить
M T
M T - 22.08.2023 21:19

En büyük Beşiktaş

Ответить
Gözde Kurt
Gözde Kurt - 22.08.2023 21:18

Iranian lady introduced herself with turkic rooted word (checked out in ethimological dictionary) "ben" or "men" means "I" in turkish at least...

Ответить
sasan mohamadzade
sasan mohamadzade - 22.08.2023 16:13

این دختر که از ایرانه از واژه عربی استفاده میکنه چون در فارسی برابر عربی هم هست این کودن از کجا پیدا کردن

Ответить
Progression Matters
Progression Matters - 22.08.2023 00:10

İnteresting topic about Turkish:

it is possible for a Turk who is has full control in turkish vocabulary to speak with using less/more arabic words or using less/more turkish words when she is speaking turkish.

For example, in Turkish when we say "hello" we generally using "selamun aleyküm" or "merhaba" which both are comes from Arabic, obviously. But also we can choose "esenlikler" which comes from Turkic origin

Using arabic/persian words much more, it's like trying to speak Ottoman Turkish.

Ответить
محمد حسین حیدریان
محمد حسین حیدریان - 21.08.2023 23:12

Persian and turkey not arabs shouldnt compare iran,tajikestan,afghanistan,samarghand and bokhara in uzbakestan and some area in daqestan and ghafghaz persian language

Ответить
Samah Alhrbe
Samah Alhrbe - 21.08.2023 16:52

موضوع اللغات و اللهجات مثير للأهتمام فعلاً ، كشخص من السعودية احنا نعرف تماماً ان الايرانيين و الاتراك ما يتكلمون العربية ، لكن يستخدمون بعض الكلمات العربية بنطق مختلف عن النطق العربي ، لكن مو بس الاتراك و الايرانيين اللي يستخدمون بعض الكلمات العربية بلغتهم حتى اسبانيا و ايطاليا لكن اسبانيا اكثر شئ يتكلمون بعض الكلمات العربية لكن بنطق مختلف كمان ، و مؤخرا اكتشفت اننا بالسعودية نستخدم القليل من الكلمات الايطاليه بسبب التأثير الثقافي و الصناعي و كان الموضوع بالنسبة لي صدمه لأني كنت اعتقد انها كلمات عربيه 😂 ، اتمنى تسوون فيديو ثاني و تعطونهم مساحه اكبر يتكلمون بلهجاتهم بأستخدام جمل اطول و متأكده ان الناس راح تنذهل من تنوع اللهجات العربية مثلا البنت اليمنية لو تكلمت اكثر متأكدة بعض البنات ماراح يفهمونها 😅 حتى التونسية و المغربية و اللبنانية لأنهم يستخدمون الفرنسي كثير ، و كمان البنت السعودية لو تكلمت بلهجتها اعتقد انهم ماراح يفهمون عليها ببعض الكلمات ، اعتقد بالمقطع حسيت انهم تكلموا بالانجليزي اكثر من لغاتهم و لهجاتهم، حتى التركية و الايرانية ما اعطوهم مساحه نسمع فيها لغاتهم بشكل كويس لأن الجمل متوقعه و محدده .

Ответить