Vocal Coach Reacts to Best Arab Singing

You don’t understand the speed to do these runs and style of music changes the way you shape your mouth
You literally can’t do any of these

You don’t understand the music or culture
These are Arabic scales also known as exotic scales

For a vocal coach i m sorry to say you need more culture in music

Just like in Flamenco ❤

Pathetic to call urself a "vocal coach" when ur a very strong "nasal talker"

U are very uncultured and it shows.

Btw those notes weren't "out of tune" they were perfect and you couldn't match them if u tried... 😅

Just cause it doesn't fit with ur western style of "singing" if u can even call that, doesn't mean it's wrong ur out of tune.

I've found ur video again after a few years and watched it again but the dislike still stands strong.

Its so hard to see you disrespecting this thousands of years old singing practise just cause u have no clue what ur talking about.

And btw yeah the shaking of the microphone obviously does something 🤷‍♂️🤷‍♂️ u ever had a microphone in your hand??

Your ONE Pound reactor!! / Arabic vocal forbidden for ignorance individual s. Please don't do it again. You have no knowledge. Let me tell you something. The first instrument come to the world from ARABIC COUNTRY.

Lol arabic singing is not at all like western singing

I wonder who compiled this video... it's a mix of amatures, professionals, stars.. old and new ... at least give Assala more room :-)

It's funny how 80% of Arabic songs are sad and depressing, but the people are usually very joyful and happy

This art is so deep that cannot be judged .... Anyone seems to be so small to judge Arabic art .... Simply they cant understand

Love this channel

We move our heads with the music because music makes us move and feel. It’s one more form of expression and it also might help some people with accentuating

they're all exaggerating .. i would suggest Majida el Roumi , Fayrouz and Abir Nehmeh . the Lebanese music is simple and modest but very powerful technically ... Arabs like to exaggerate , Lebanese are the opposite which makes them closer and more liked by westerners

Howdy!

The individual who sent you this collection has no taste of what is good Arabic music. These artists or vocalists are not well known except for 3. Also, these voices are very young and out of the line of the real Arabic music/schools. Many of us Arabs don't listen to them.
I dont blame you on your reactions towards the vocals, you were very polite and honest. I really hope someone would send you real Arabic music vocalists like Khadum Alsahir, Faizruz, Om Kalthoom, Raja Bolemleeh....etc as the collection in this received video made me ashamed to listen to them as an Arabic poet and critic.
Stay amazing! Thank you again!

Said you can not feel or apresiate the beauty and majestic of this singing, while we as Arabs our ears are educated to appreciate all kind of music back ground....

The first girl singing was actually out of tune even in Arabic singing you are right

Really fun to watch you react and listen to something fro which you of course are unfamiliar.. thanks, and thanks to whoever assembled these clips.

Here there are the influences of flamenco, and you can see it in Eaea for example

babe your fav artists are inspired by arabic scales but suree

Please dont speak about something you have even knowledge about it and dont even judge Arabic music and singing and say they dont have a technique we'll know arabs deported al lots of musical instruments and technique to ur culture and i advice u to keep judging Arian grande music and leave the arabic music alone.

la musique arabe est sensuelle elle sort des tripes rien à voir avec la musique occidentale comme la danse orientale les occidentaux ne connaissent rien à part eux même

Coach, can I learn to sing ? I play the guitar but I can’t sing! Do you give private lessons online?

I would rather listen to this style of singing than any other on the planet. I instantly get chills, tears in my eyes and I take pause, my breath catches in my throat, all becomes still and timeless when I hear it.

This is why we don’t want white people colonizing us—y’all can’t tell how incredible Assalah is 😂 you’ll get there… we have thousands of years of culture on you, don’t feel bad.

First we should know if there s an "arab singing " . I think from one country to another and from one epoch to another, and there are different styles

This is Arabian Melisma. It's standard and very popular in almost all Arab countries. It's kind of a prelude to the main song.

never ever again the western scale has no business being compared to centuries old techniques, scales, storytelling, and breath work

The two persons you've liked are Palestinians ... Mohammed Assaf and Adham Nabulsi.

Arabic always use same rythm,unique and difficult. I am not a moslem, but for me maqam bayati rythm is the most beautiful rhytm.

My most favourite arab singer is Mohammed Abdou😊. I hope you see and comment on his singing too😉.

To be honest with you, arabic singers are way better, we arabic people when we hear celine dione mariah or whitney, that doesn't suprise us since we're used to it in our culture (the runs agility melismatic, emotions, lyricism..)

It was HONEST. THANKS

First you need to listen more to Arabic music until your ears gets used to it so you can analyze better, and its not bad to educate yourself on arabic music and not judge it from one angle, what you did was eating sushi with spoon when you have to eat it with chop sticks.
Not even all of them are arabic songs, some of them are not arabic songs.
You did not even talk much about the techniques, you were talking more about facial expressions which is something shallow to do or say. This makes me doupt your credibility in judging western music as well, after all you are not that honest.

And of course thanks Georgina to have choosen the trinity of best arabic music and voices : Algerians 🇩🇿, Lebaneses 🇱🇧 and Egyptians 🇪🇬 !

I recommend you delve deeper into the subject. What you deemed as out of tune or off key was simply not. It is due to the lack of knowledge about the genre. These are masters of their craft. Thanks.

So happy to see Arabic music/style being showcased on your wonderful channel! Although I would recommend watching/reacting to some full performances of well known artists ( for example, a Mai Farouk performance with the National Arab Orchestra doing songs like Enta Omri or Alf Leila w Leila) as this particular clip you've reacted to is merely a random compilation of artists riffing and thus doesn't cover the full range of musicality, complexity and emotions that Arabic music brings to the table.

it not out of tunes , just arabic tunes is different because of the arabic language , there is more sounds and pronunciations that make arabes hoarseness unique, so they hit more notes / tunes . and the techniques vary from country to country so it a really vast world for a coach to understand, arabe singers find non arabe music easy and they can easily handle the western style, thats a fact.. you can see it in the westerns competitions .. , if you cant understand something doesn't mean it not the right way, you are just not open mind enough to critic your own coaching.
that's the problem with most westerns, we understand you , your language , your music , your culture, your history , your books and so on .. but you know nothing about us , most arabes speaks at least 2 or 3 different languages, most westerns speaks only their local language .. so i invite with all respect the western community to approach us, dont close your minds .. dont follow the propaganda.
the amount of pre judgments you made is an evidence .. dont make the standards of your culture a judgement for all human kind , it doesnt work that way.. hope you dont find my comment offensive.. but someone has to say it, for the sake of connection and building bridges.
sorry for getting sensitive

your comment about cheb mami's singing that you wouldn't accept in your studio, what cheb mami is doing is over 2k years old. I think you and the people at your studio should learn more, and get more cultured about supersets of music I'm sure you are unaware of and would benefit from instead of your unqualified opinion.

I think you can’t give an accurate feedback or comment about these since it’s very different than western music there is lot of 1/4 notes in arabic music and a western vocal coach can’t understand that

That's fantastic

You definitely had some shady hateful comments

My dear....,
You know only one type of music...is western. It will require much more research for you to understand eastern music...

Wow All of the are Outstanding 😭❤️❤️

Disregarding the fact that arab singing is much more than what she's portraying, what she's judging is not one style of riffs only but she's comparing several types of singing styles (called lyrical maqamat) that aren't supposed to be compared to one another and as she has noticed differ alot in technique.

Please react next to:
1. Dalia - “ali yemshi aadi”
2. Rahma - “al kokab”
3. Ghazal - “ma atnazal”
4. Aseel - “al mafrod”

Listen to umm kulthum i bet you will like her

She is not the best singer!!! Excuse me!!!!
We have too many!!!!