Комментарии:
Was this tittle a joke 😂😂😂😂
ОтветитьAll I want is for John and Danny to end up together to feed into the fantasy genre. Martin said it is a bitter sweet ending for his books, I want the John and Danny together being the sweet side of that. As much as I love Tyrian, Sansa, Arya, Jamie, and others I understand that they could all be the “bitter” side of the ending. But please Martin…John and Danny can’t end the way they did in the show…I’m still not emotionally recovered from what they did to my Queen and King.
ОтветитьI don’t like when authors write updates like this. GRRM isn’t the first and I doubt he’ll be the last. I’ve had a few “favorite” authors do this and it’s just ridiculous. Diana Gabaldon also did this and her new book has been out for awhile and I haven’t read it. I don’t know why I just got tired of the whole thing.I’m not at that point with GOT but whenever I see merch or watch a clip I think about how annoying it is. Just once I wish these writers would think about the fans. Keep up the great work on your channel and loved your ending to GOT thanks!
ОтветитьIf there’s gonna be a huge debate about which ending is better i’ll cry
ОтветитьI'm so envious of George RR Martin because I've always wanted to produce a work of art, a publication that was as perfect as Songs of Ice and Fire! It's simply brilliant but has raised the bar so high, making it almost impossible to produce something that is as great as that! I used to think that Lord of the Rings was The GOAT until he created this magnificent piece of work!! What a guy! What a great, imaginative writer he is. He's now definitely my favourite author of all time. Name one author that you think is better? 🤔
ОтветитьDear George RR Martin, as a fan of both the books and the TV series, I accepted them the way they are and would not conclude that the series ending is a disaster but a masterpiece instead, some of TV's most powerful and memorable moments. As for the remaining books yet to be published, I have to say this: Don't give me what I want. Give me what you want. True creativity requires a reader's maturity to fully appreciate it.
ОтветитьI dont read the books and probably never will but the tv ending annoys me. Puzzles me why he is taking so long. I waa hoping they would one day redo th ending or make a triple a video game with the actora from the show that gives a better ending.
ОтветитьI think that the ending that we got could work in the books if all these various fates are built towards properly and telegraphed logically instead of rushed as was the case of the TV show. Except for Arya killing the Night king. No amount of finessing will make that an acceptable outcome.
ОтветитьI just wanted him to finish the two last books instead of him making others
ОтветитьMost likely part of his extended time finishing book 6 is probably due to re-writes from parts of the show being true to the books that he realized really made fans upset and disappointed. Just speculating of course.
ОтветитьThe best thing he's said about this whole books being delayed is in an interview where he says something like "10 years from now, everyone will talk about how good the books were, not how late they released.
ОтветитьI like the fact that george is humble enough to say "some will like the ending of the show".
ОтветитьThis has to be the best update I've had so far and to be honest, I saw that coming.
What I'm confused about is whether future sequels(not formal yet), take place after the ending of got or asoiaf.
That could be a whole debate knowing that the show will put the future writers so many inevitable rabbit holes.
I liked the ending of GOT but thats because I corrected it with my own head canon. In my head basically Bran warged to the past and Became Bran the Builder so he could help save humanity from the first long night. Then manipulated all of the events leading up to his coronation, so he could sit the Throne as a Champion for the old gods so that he could protect the last remaining children of the forest. He and John Snow would forge a new pact with the remaining children ushering a new magical era for Westeros. He searches for Droggon so he could warg into the Dragon and enforce this new pact. John becomes the King of the freefolk and preserves the culture of the first men north of the wall.
ОтветитьTo the Garden!
ОтветитьImagine a world where authors can interact with fans and mold their stories with input from those fans. GRRM is the first to experience and use this. He saw first hand how fans reacted to his ideas on the show
ОтветитьI'm just just going to say it I've never seen an 8o year old man that fat... He doesn't have long to finish these books
ОтветитьHe has a contingency plan incase he dies before its made. He has people that will finish it based on his ideas so we are safe there! We will get this book at some point
Ответитьhes a man but not the other two things
Ответитьminsdqq1
ОтветитьJust read exactly what he said. You're interpreting. I should've read it myself instead. Useless, misleading video.
ОтветитьI plant a small tree
In hopes that one day it will
See winds of winter
كلشي ما افتهم بالانكليزي ممكن اخد يوضحلي شجاي يحجي باختصار ؟
ОтветитьI don't think the books will have a great ending either. The books are kind of a mess and have to many half fleshed out threads and the story would need more than 2 books imho. I mean in the books Jon snow for example is barley even developed at this point. Plus its clearly not his priority anymore. The show fell apart but in some ways the first seasons were better than the books.
ОтветитьHe's never going to finish the books.
ОтветитьSeason 6 - 8 have so bad writing… I’m so excited for the book 😂
ОтветитьJust finish the books George.
ОтветитьThat lazy f*ck....
ОтветитьImagine having such an uncreative brain that you ask “where do you get your ideas”.
Ответить"The book is coming along" is the same response we've had for years now , so this update is a big load of nothingness.
ОтветитьThe I.D.
ОтветитьI doubt he'll ever finish it
ОтветитьMost likely he's at least referring to Barristan Selmay not dying.
ОтветитьWait 11 years for Winds of Winter, wait another 11 years for a promise of spring. I think not. Martin is just too full of himself to complete his work in a timely manner.
ОтветитьI can't imagine how many people have died waiting for him to finish this.
ОтветитьIt's been 11 years, I've forgotten a lot of it by now and I'm not reading 5000+ pages again to read the conclusion without having to go "who? what? where was he at last time? what's going on with this one again?".
I'm done with ASOIAF and I deeply regret wasting my time the first 5 books.
y'all gotta let the man work. we can't give him more reasons to put time into these explanations. he's 74 years old.
ОтветитьSome fans will auto-hate??? How dare they? This is Lord of the Pen
ОтветитьI think the TV-show ruined a lot of twists and turns, and developments that could have worked really well in the books, simply because it spoiled the end result. having a plot or a character evolve naturally towards one of the endings in the show could be really exciting if you don't know where the story is heading, but if you know where it's going I think a lot of the story will just feel like it's trying to justify why it's ending in a certian way. Or at least, the books will feel more like an explanation that an actual story.
ОтветитьId, like idd. Not I.D.
ОтветитьCersei aligns and marries with Young Griff, they have a dragon
ОтветитьMost encouraging update I've heard in years.
ОтветитьGlad to see very positive comments here🙌❤️. I get so sick of people bad mouthing George just cause they’re pissed about the next book taking forever. Kinda understandable ig but no need to hate on the man. I only hope he lives many healthy years to come & get his great work finished.
ОтветитьBro why are you changing words that are right up on the screen? If you're gonna just show screenshots and read the text, read it verbatim. Why are you paraphrasing and restructuring sentences? Changing "but" to "however," and "you all" to "all of you," etc.
Why? Not only are you changing his words, but it's annoying as hell to be reading along and have words/phrases changed by the narrator. It's like you're trying to put your own take on his words. There's no need. Just read what you're presenting. The obvious exception being the typo that you fixed (if to is, iirc).
It's been so darmn long. I barely remember half the characters mentioned in the letter. I'm not rereading the books. I'm not even sure I'll read the 6th book at this point. Maybe eventually but I'm in no hurry.
ОтветитьOne fear I have (and it might be morbid) is that GRRM dies before releasing WoW and/or DoS.
George is 74 years old, morbidly obese and I am pretty sure he has gathered a lot of health issues along the way.
I know it sounds pretty selfish to be concerned about someone's health primarily because I want that person to write books I wanna read, but I am just honest.
The only positive comments I heard about Season 8 came from some of the sycophantic actors.
ОтветитьWords are wind George. Stop dreaming up mystery boxes and Give us Winds of Winter.
Ответить