UNREAL ENGINE 5 vs CORONA which is better for Architectural Rendering?

UNREAL ENGINE 5 vs CORONA which is better for Architectural Rendering?

Stan3DArt

1 год назад

220,429 Просмотров

Can the Unreal Engine 5 provide quality comparable to Corona Render or Vray under equal conditions and on same hardware? To answer this question, I made the same scene in 3Ds Max with Corona and Unreal Engine 5.1.
I will also compare Lumen and Ray Tracing reflection to get the best result.
Part 2: https://youtu.be/Rv2tQUCgIsc

00:00 Introduction
00:24 3DsMax Corona scene
02:13 Unreal Engine scene
02:06 UE Lumen scene settings
04:03 Rendering 3Ds Max Corona
04:05 My PC hardware specifications
05:08 Rendering UE Lumen
06:20 Corona vs UE Lumen
09:09 Corona vs UE Ray Tracing reflections
09:43 My opinion

🔥My Course - Сreating Architectural Interactive Visualization🔥
👉 https://youtu.be/u-8lGIYv_-I

Complite scene (Project source files) UE 5.1:
https://www.patreon.com/posts/ue-5-vs-corona-77746733?utm_medium=clipboard_copy&utm_source=copyLink&utm_campaign=postshare_creator&utm_content=join_link

All renders: https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/15PFNvwp83MSnxw4yqznuC0FFfCHiAwDR?usp=share_link

Support me on patreon:
https://www.patreon.com/stan3dart

Follow me on Instagram:
https://www.instagram.com/stanzhuikov/

Music:
@Sappheiros - Reaching Out

Тэги:

#Unreal_engine #unreal_engine_5 #corona_render #archviz #architecture #rendering #3ds_max #architectural_rendering #unreal_engine_rendering #ue #ue5 #visualization #architecture_visualization #exterior #exterior_rendering #render
Ссылки и html тэги не поддерживаются


Комментарии:

@joesayle2213
@joesayle2213 - 28.01.2023 10:47

I have been in the archviz industry for 20 plus years and as cool as realtime is the comparison is not a very good representation of a paid project. Most projects require more complex environments with 100's of assets and more complex shader setups. Also if you first put the scene together in Max and then export to unreal your doubling up on work. It would be interesting to see how it would handle a low rise residential project with full landscaping and high end interiors.

Ответить
@user-tm9ue7gi5q
@user-tm9ue7gi5q - 22.12.2023 17:42

nice

Ответить
@gorgona1984
@gorgona1984 - 06.12.2023 00:24

After over 14 years of utilizing 3dsMax and V-Ray at our small architectural firm, we decided to explore Unreal Engine 5. Following numerous proof-of-concept projects, we have reached the firm conclusion that embracing Unreal Engine is the most pragmatic choice, factoring in considerations such as costs, rendering quality, onboarding new team members, and project delivery timelines.

In contrast to the substantial expense associated with a 3-year subscription of 3dsMax 2023 in the USA, priced at $5,625, Unreal Engine, available for free, emerged as a clear and compelling alternative. The decision to transition was, without a doubt, a no-brainer, aligning seamlessly with our commitment to efficiency, financial prudence, and innovative project workflows.

Ответить
@rain-2779
@rain-2779 - 30.11.2023 18:21

Thank you for sharing. For me, Corona probably only win the reflection...(it does really good actually), but consider the time and environment, UE5 >>> CORONA)

Ответить
@BeproStudio
@BeproStudio - 26.11.2023 16:19

Unreal is fun, until the client needs changes. still, the corona render is extremely useful for this industry.
just try to set up Architectural Glass in Unreal, 50 clicks until the materials are visible.

Ответить
@claudianreyn4529
@claudianreyn4529 - 10.10.2023 01:40

The materials and the shadows are more realistic in Corona.

Ответить
@joelmulder
@joelmulder - 03.10.2023 05:33

UE5 is free, Corona is rather expensive, easy choice for me.

Ответить
@bogdanoff_by
@bogdanoff_by - 27.09.2023 22:20

ue is better

Ответить
@imedhamdi862
@imedhamdi862 - 11.09.2023 12:35

please can you make a full tutrial from A to Z for beginner and slow tutorial for full architecture project!! it gonna help us really please!!

Ответить
@pawnix4122
@pawnix4122 - 07.09.2023 15:17

If you want to fix the shadow issue under the roof of the front most building, all you have to do it to activate contact shadows and potentially play with shadow offset. That should solve the shadow problem completely with no side effects

Ответить
@i.f.7386
@i.f.7386 - 07.09.2023 09:24

Terrible accent 😂

Ответить
@irender-3dvisualisaties375
@irender-3dvisualisaties375 - 30.08.2023 18:39

How did you make the background and the ground?

Ответить
@theperfectwheel6895
@theperfectwheel6895 - 22.08.2023 08:34

Diggi, ich komm voll runter bei deinen Videos. Entspannung pur.

Ответить
@baruel1731
@baruel1731 - 17.08.2023 04:02

UNREAL 5 INCOMPÁRAVEL !!!!!!!!!

Ответить
@tp670tp670
@tp670tp670 - 07.08.2023 09:19

我一直在3DMAX上使用Vray的GPU,最近開始使用Unreal,效果跟速度真的出乎意料的好,速度甚至比Lumion快

Ответить
@ExacoMvm
@ExacoMvm - 12.07.2023 17:30

Imo the workflow of UE5 is so slow that the realtime speed of it isn't really worth it e.g. you setup fairly complex exterior city scene in UE5 in 10 days and render instantly, meanwhile you can setup same scene in 3D Package in like 3 days and render in like 1 hour so you basically save 7 days of time using old 3D package workflow and get better result in that "imaginary" scenario since 3D Packages does everything better and way more efficient such as shading workflow, lighting, object/material outliner systems, animation, UI/UX, loading/processing times, etc. for example think about shading a car procedurally in UE5 vs Corona to get it photoreal using just few essential bitmaps, I could do whole car in Corona in like 1-2 hours, meanwhile it would take probably like 1-2 hours just to make basic glass or carpaint material in UE5.
However huge advantage of UE5 would be for animations and likely (V)RAM usage, I guess you can throw a lot more textures in UE5 compared to Corona, etc and ofc there's Nanite.

Ответить
@otalcre
@otalcre - 12.07.2023 01:27

can you get good results with a non RTX board? (with a gtx e.g)

Ответить
@sikanderkhan4528
@sikanderkhan4528 - 03.07.2023 21:46

UE be like = you kidding me🤣🤣🤣🤣

Ответить
@wtTendou96
@wtTendou96 - 28.06.2023 15:56

I really like the comparison it is more detailed, unlike other channels who only scratch the surface of other software for comparison

Ответить
@marquisdetufblablablabla
@marquisdetufblablablabla - 26.06.2023 00:31

vray is the best

Ответить
@archcast5550
@archcast5550 - 08.06.2023 00:31

Subscribing you deserve an epic megagrant!

Ответить
@metken_
@metken_ - 06.06.2023 09:54

so corona is better or not?

Ответить
@user-uc2vs6rj3z
@user-uc2vs6rj3z - 30.05.2023 04:24

the way i see it, unreal better than corono

Ответить
@user-pw1df8sj3w
@user-pw1df8sj3w - 22.05.2023 23:59

Its "this", not "ziz"... :D Im not russophobe, but you guys out there are got some addiction to Z..... indians are more funny with english btw.

Ответить
@user-ih6cs9ms4q
@user-ih6cs9ms4q - 17.05.2023 00:59

thanks for your Description

Ответить
@user-ih6cs9ms4q
@user-ih6cs9ms4q - 17.05.2023 00:56

thanks for your

Ответить
@newrandomguy4218
@newrandomguy4218 - 15.05.2023 22:09

I'm not a robot! 😹

Ответить
@sachin_salve7694
@sachin_salve7694 - 29.04.2023 08:56

huge Thanks..!!! That's what I was searching for..!!!

Ответить
@daikon711
@daikon711 - 27.04.2023 22:06

you can enable raytraced shadows for lumen, in project settings, which should get rid of the artifacts

Ответить
@gonanavasdosaches
@gonanavasdosaches - 21.04.2023 23:40

se ve cabron ese proyecto de la pc

Ответить
@StevenPogorelov
@StevenPogorelov - 21.04.2023 14:37

I love the accent

Ответить
@meta.hariharan
@meta.hariharan - 15.04.2023 09:19

while using path tracing in unreal engine . glass visibility are low. How can I increase the visiblity of that!

Ответить
@whatsappvideos9665
@whatsappvideos9665 - 11.04.2023 11:37

For real world purposes of architecture, where its about showing the client the renders, either will do. This level of scrutiny is only necessary if it's a movie render.

Ответить
@SAURAVKUMAR-cs7lx
@SAURAVKUMAR-cs7lx - 10.04.2023 10:57

something wrong with his voice but content is superb. may be he is using some kinda AI voice 😁😁

Ответить
@9An_NE-prX
@9An_NE-prX - 10.04.2023 09:25

ماذا عن لوميون 12؟

Ответить
@3dnerd-
@3dnerd- - 07.04.2023 13:10

HI Stan3DArt,
can you please make video animation tutorial in 3dsmax x Corona render like you did with UE 5 "Cabin in the Rocks". Thank you

Ответить
@HellPedre
@HellPedre - 31.03.2023 14:15

LMAO people defending offline rendering in 2023??? for real??? UE is a revolution, I personally give offline renders 1, 2 years tops, the insane gain on render time and real time previs with an almost final quality look is unheard of, that only without even mentioning libraries, FX, ease of use, interactivity is enough to kill all other render engines. so Offline rendering is finally dead!! Thanks Nvidia!

Ответить
@infojaviernova
@infojaviernova - 29.03.2023 14:21

Muy buen tutorial para poder comparar, muchas cosas. Gracias y saludos desde España :)
Very good tutorial to be able to compare, many things. Thanks and greetings from Spain :)

Ответить
@kevindrexler2030
@kevindrexler2030 - 29.03.2023 11:26

Hizer...........))))) Now this is the accent))

Ответить
@TheTomik7
@TheTomik7 - 28.03.2023 09:15

Ziomek jest sztuczną inteligencją :D

Ответить
@SuperSven1994
@SuperSven1994 - 26.03.2023 15:00

3Ds Max is a ancient mamonth crap

Ответить
@user-rh1no7fp9l
@user-rh1no7fp9l - 26.03.2023 00:11

Русский что ли?

Ответить
@Gektor3000
@Gektor3000 - 25.03.2023 01:54

енжин...

Ответить
@QBright
@QBright - 24.03.2023 17:35

Харош брат

Ответить
@ArnoM86
@ArnoM86 - 23.03.2023 15:59

Wich graphics card are you using? Thank you

Ответить
@fraijilouay9239
@fraijilouay9239 - 23.03.2023 10:41

how does this channel have only 4.9 k subs..man this is one of the most interesting channels for learning all about the architecture

Ответить
@asssssghghgh
@asssssghghgh - 22.03.2023 15:24

амэйзинг для всех

Ответить
@dirkschiller1637
@dirkschiller1637 - 22.03.2023 05:06

Why you resync your videos and do not record your voice directly ?

Ответить
@phpn99
@phpn99 - 21.03.2023 23:12

Are you an AI ?

Ответить