Why Communism is a Failed Religion

Why Communism is a Failed Religion

Whatifalthist

1 год назад

478,692 Просмотров

Ссылки и html тэги не поддерживаются


Комментарии:

@WhatifAltHist
@WhatifAltHist - 09.06.2023 09:32

Sorry gang. I made a slip up when I said Voltaire let his children starve and liked being spanked. I misspoke and meant his rival Rousseau. Voltaire was widely seen as an incredibly intelligent, moral, witty and generally well liked person at the time, while Rousseau was the opposite.

Ответить
@pabsmanhere
@pabsmanhere - 11.02.2024 20:57

Please don't say Judeo-Christian... yuck.

Ответить
@knobjob2839
@knobjob2839 - 11.02.2024 19:52

Dude, you really don't understand what Naziism is. Nazis were top down, big government, collectivist, socialists. That a feminine way of thinking by your own logic. Get this crap right. You sound stupid.

Ответить
@brettshipton1355
@brettshipton1355 - 11.02.2024 12:14

Communism is NOT a religion.

Ответить
@kimobrien.
@kimobrien. - 08.02.2024 20:34

This shows what a shallow thinker this man actually is. In his whole list of source material I do NOT see the names Marx, Engles, Lenin, Trotsky, Castro or Guevara. Nor do I see the names James Cannon, Eugene Debs, or Farrell Dobbs. What he has is a list mostly of people who wrote ABOUT communists or communism and not much else. Want to read the real deal see The Militant newspaper.

Ответить
@philosophynwar
@philosophynwar - 08.02.2024 07:38

Capitalism is a failed form of oppression.

Ответить
@Cha4k
@Cha4k - 07.02.2024 09:25

I remember when I was younger and surrounded by communist friends. I thought "Yea I guess communism probably is good, Make everything fair, Sounds reasonable."
Then I started to notice that all of them had high anxiety, Were all very angry and scared of the world and were generally very greedy and motivated by anger that others had more than them even if they themselves were well off.
Some of them started making statements like "The working class don't know what's good for them, That's why we should be in charge"
I realized more and more how counter to human nature the whole idea was and how it just assumed this would magically change.
It doesn't work, And kids should be taught this in schools.
I can forgive younger people for being this naïve but when older people are communists its really pathetic.

Ответить
@mechengineer4life
@mechengineer4life - 07.02.2024 01:09

Hilarious how he thought his philosophy was insightful because, why do some people have so much and so many have so little?? Well gee, because we are all born with no skills, no ability to feed ourselves or find shelter, etc. etc.

Ответить
@Webedunn
@Webedunn - 06.02.2024 21:04

COMMUNISM SUX! It’s simply the lazy and dumb that seize power then run all progress right into the dirt!

Ответить
@sandercypher6516
@sandercypher6516 - 05.02.2024 04:32

I think communism is the antichrists vehicle to power in revelations. I liked the wording he used that communism is the twisted mirror reflection of Christianity

Ответить
@roughshart5870
@roughshart5870 - 03.02.2024 01:07

Just watching this video made me feel incredibly red-pilled and based.

Ответить
@kanssamatkustaja
@kanssamatkustaja - 31.01.2024 14:31

You could have at least looked into what Marx said before making this video. You literally have no idea what Marx wrote, you could have found out even by just googling, but you are too lazy.

Ответить
@source3nergy203
@source3nergy203 - 31.01.2024 01:08

Hmm

Ответить
@DeadpoolX9
@DeadpoolX9 - 29.01.2024 02:40

The left side of the body uses the right hemisphere:::))))

Left hand magic just gets hijacked by degenerates more often than not.

Ответить
@happybeejv
@happybeejv - 27.01.2024 22:13

If communism is gnostic?
Then is capitalism taoist?
The invisible hand of the market implies actionless action
You can't force it you have to go with the flow

Ответить
@user-md1uq2rp3f
@user-md1uq2rp3f - 25.01.2024 22:32

A friend asked me don't you want equal stuff. I told him no i wanted
to work to get every advantage I could get.

Ответить
@ahmedmahmud4238
@ahmedmahmud4238 - 25.01.2024 01:39

Communism was just a facade for promoting antiChristianity. If that doesnt work try Liberalism, if that doesnt work try Libertarianism, if that doesnt work...etc...you people ought to medidate on the meaning of being Gods Rejected People, it means Jesus Envy.

Ответить
@ahmedmahmud4238
@ahmedmahmud4238 - 25.01.2024 01:36

In all honesty, the Encyclopedist, and specially Voltaire, were mere propagandist and falsifiers of science and history. You know people like them today, ever met somebody who worships science but has no capacity to do it? Somebody who worships science but would probably fail calculus? These are low iq groupies whos subsitituted critical thinking with the worship of science, and 1, 2, 3 there you have Voltaire.

Ответить
@ahmedmahmud4238
@ahmedmahmud4238 - 25.01.2024 01:08

Since right wingers are constantly being fed disinformation, it is no wonder right wingers loose constantly agains the left. The first map in this video marks south America as the same civilization as Saudi Arabia and Iran 😂. I mean that is just laughable. Where does India get its color? Its it's own civilization. Just utter nonesense. These academics put out whatever their masters tell them, and they just spin the yard until they weave whatever narrative their masters want. @Whatalthist should not get upset for calling out b.s.

Ответить
@tacdriver911
@tacdriver911 - 21.01.2024 21:55

Communism will never work because of Ego, Greed and Megalomania.

Ответить
@MercuryTheVexilliologyNerd
@MercuryTheVexilliologyNerd - 17.01.2024 18:51

what about Capitalism and the hundreds of failed capitalist states? oh wait, none of them failed "because of capitalism" its corruption or some other poor excuse.

Capitalism is a disease that mitigates its way into every facet of a persons life, it only exists to uphold the elite and exploit everyone else, why else do you think the US government is run by oligarchs in big oil, military contractors, and tech? both parties are bought and paid for by these oligarchs. Capitalism IS the enemy.

Ответить
@user-FUCKYOU18
@user-FUCKYOU18 - 17.01.2024 07:07

Communism are ALL different

Ответить
@user-oq1ng9eb1b
@user-oq1ng9eb1b - 16.01.2024 20:27

Cuba is such a shining example that people are willing to swim from the tip of Florida to get on the island.

Ответить
@josephmagdalen9220
@josephmagdalen9220 - 16.01.2024 13:10

Marx = Peice of $hit!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!...So says a Cuban who lived through Communism!

Ответить
@doctornonsense4726
@doctornonsense4726 - 14.01.2024 03:26

love most of your videos, but felt you let your opinions taint the content in this one

Ответить
@KenM_1987
@KenM_1987 - 13.01.2024 11:14

Communism is a way to be ruled by tinpot dictators controlled by drunk depraved clowns in the Kremlin. Alternatively a surveillance genocidal (same as Russia) state such as China.

Ответить
@KingTragic02
@KingTragic02 - 12.01.2024 00:34

Brother idk what you are talking about when you say Christanity is a feminine mindset by say all ppl are equal when we believe all ppl are created in the image of god not all ppl can do everything we have roles woman are in the submissive role such as not being able to teach men not being able to be pastors they are to obey their husbands etc men must live their women as Jesus loved the church fathers must not provoke their children but not spare the rod so no we simply life the way god wanted us too but don’t mistake that as something similar to a feminine view of the world as we both know a feminine view which is the modern feminist is very anti Christian

Ответить
@lexiph3721
@lexiph3721 - 07.01.2024 23:33

I love how bro puts sources in the description. Istg no one else does this and it’s so disheartening.

Ответить
@Disapproving_Welsh_Corgi
@Disapproving_Welsh_Corgi - 06.01.2024 11:50

I love that this really is an alternate history of our world since there are so few actual facts in this video

Ответить
@christopherbettridge5983
@christopherbettridge5983 - 03.01.2024 13:26

There has been no successful economic system that helps their poor; your analysis is the epitome of a failed version of an ideal condition ie; your own
inherent need to maintain exploitative patriarchal social structures. There majority of your points are based upon a personal flawed view of your own place in the world as compared to the "lazy, stupid and useless" amongst us. The ideal of a non self destructive structure of human cooperation over a system that by it's own nature necessitates a constant growth on a planet, indeed a universe which has finite resources. It's easy to make arguments about the system which is the one which has encompassed everything within its own rubric. No truly Socialist system has ever been put in place yet; the few that have appeared have been crushed by the dominant power which is a capitalist one. Telling me that the things which I know in my heart to be true (I don't know what idiots you've been having discourses with but fuck them they don't represent socialism) is so insulting it shows that your critiques are based on nothing more than the ideal of the dominant working to retain his own position. Which in any realistic version of Socialism you could retain anyways. Be well

Ответить
@arkady7739
@arkady7739 - 02.01.2024 17:52

You know you never read any of the source material you provided.

Ответить
@tylerwellman8634
@tylerwellman8634 - 02.01.2024 05:34

Maybe there is a problem with some of these Jews

Ответить
@paull3278
@paull3278 - 31.12.2023 05:38

Communism is perhaps the single most dangerous memetic virus yet to be invented.

Ответить
@shaneboydston2395
@shaneboydston2395 - 29.12.2023 07:04

Hi, I'm new here but I kind of agree with a lot of what you have to say. I don't get it in full yet if I'm being honest. Yet your video essays are deliciously informative. I just need something answered if you're willing to take the time. You say we needed to return to religion, art, and philosophy. Yet, some people have "religious trauma" for lack of a better term because of the people. What would you propose as a religion if given the choice to make a new one? As the only way I see us moving forward after the high possibility of a revolution is making our own.

Ответить
@momcilopucar8749
@momcilopucar8749 - 29.12.2023 04:12

❤Commuism♥️ never failed. There Never have been any communism. It was a socialism in infant stages that 👉🇺🇲US had subverted/sabotaged.

Ответить
@martinbowman1993
@martinbowman1993 - 28.12.2023 19:40

Those who can't do teach - those who can't teach, teach Physical Education.
Academics see themselves as the philosopher knigs of the Platonic Republic, but they neglect the part that Alexander the Great was a philosopher king. He left the schoolhouse and proved his performance ability through conquest.

Ответить
@rollingmancave4547
@rollingmancave4547 - 27.12.2023 19:41

Whatifalthist has a lot of great content, but he is young, naive, and gets a lot of stuff wrong.

Ответить
@rollingmancave4547
@rollingmancave4547 - 27.12.2023 19:14

Hey, wake up! There has never been a Communist Country, ever! A truly Communist country would be ownership by ALL the people. There would still be personal private property! Everything else would be owned by each and every person! Communism would be much closer to a true democracy than the USA can ever claim to be. Oh, and religion has tons more negative impacts than its few benefits. Religion has rules, and those rules limit your freedom.

Ответить
@Classical404
@Classical404 - 26.12.2023 13:48

How iš national socialism "toxically masculine”?

Ответить
@ayadali9112
@ayadali9112 - 25.12.2023 19:14

It’s an ideology. Not a religion.

Ответить
@rodseller9936
@rodseller9936 - 24.12.2023 18:53

Religion is communism. It is spiritual communism or some may say spiritual authoritarianism. It is all the same you have no freedom. You're not allowed to be your own God.

Ответить
@johnwhick7419
@johnwhick7419 - 24.12.2023 14:58

Unfortunately it isn’t failed it’s just murderous. Doesn’t seem to stop the believers.

Ответить
@andrewcameron3410
@andrewcameron3410 - 22.12.2023 22:17

This guy is gonna be real upset when he figures most of his generation are commies and that's where the whole of the west is maeching

Ответить
@Hey_Soos
@Hey_Soos - 22.12.2023 20:34

💯💯💯

Ответить
@blacklungmorgan4131
@blacklungmorgan4131 - 21.12.2023 17:55

Corporate slave 🤡

Ответить
@pmcarvajal76
@pmcarvajal76 - 20.12.2023 07:51

COMMUNISM IS A FAILED Relgion...🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣😂🤣🤣🤣🤣. YOVE NEITHER READ MARX OR LENIN.

Ответить
@peaceleader7315
@peaceleader7315 - 19.12.2023 19:42

Communism isn't a failed concept.. it is a dormant reality.. like that of seeds that wait until the right condition to grow...
Hmmmm..
With modern innovation such as artificial intelligence repetitive machines and robotic technologies when means of production are placed on the hands of innovative solutions.. hmmmm it will grow again.. and will represents our human species calculation.. !!!

Ответить
@davideriolhickman876
@davideriolhickman876 - 17.12.2023 15:11

This quote is all you need to cripple a commie >""The Communists disdain to conceal their views and aims. They openly declare that their ends can be attained only by the forcible overthrow of all existing social conditions.""

Forcible Overthrow = Violence
All Existing Social Conditions= History, Traditions, Institutions, Language, Family, Education, Moral Systems: Absolutely Everything

So, that's a No from Me. I grant no such right, and if they insist, then violence is what THEY Chose, so Violence it is...

Ответить
@davideriolhickman876
@davideriolhickman876 - 17.12.2023 15:06

It is no coincidence that the Latin for 'Left Hand' is Sinister

Ответить