The ORIGINS of the Proto Indo Europeans: Who were they?

As always, thanks for watching, and please ask as many questions as you have, and I'll do my best to answer them all.

Are the proto Europeans in the room with us right now?

Real European History :

Haplogroup R1b,R1a (Native Europeans)
(Basques/Iberians. Gaels. East Slavs.)

Haplogroup I (Neolithic Indo European wave from Anatolia.)
(Danubian Civilization) (Pottery Cultures)
(Agriculture. Megaliths. Polytheism. Pottery. Longhouses. Axes. Sailing ships. Flatbread (Tunnbröd).)
(Bosnians. Scandinavians. Sardinians)

Haplogroup J2 (Bronze Age Indo European wave.)
(Ancient Mycenean/Minoan Greece. Rome. Writing. Metallurgy. Architecture. )
(Modern Cretans)

And some lesser sporadic influxes of Haplogroup E (North Africa) and Haplogroup G (Northwest Caucasus)


R1 (Vasconic)
G (Kartvelian)
E (Afro-Asiatic)
J1 (Semitic)
I & J2 (Indo-European)

The Danish Bronze Age Sun Chariot, also known as the Trundholm Sun Chariot, is an iconic artifact from the Nordic Bronze Age. It was discovered in 1902 near Trundholm, Denmark, and dates back to approximately 1400 BCE. The Sun Chariot is considered one of the most remarkable examples of Scandinavian prehistoric art and craftsmanship.

The Sun Chariot consists of a bronze disc with a diameter of approximately 25 centimeters (10 inches), depicting a stylized sun or full moon. The disc is mounted on a bronze wagon, which has four wheels and an axle. The entire chariot measures around 60 centimeters (24 inches) in length.

New theories I’d like to hear more about and especially to get his data: didn’t know that you could dare PIE prior to 4,000 BC

Why are they called Indo-Europeans and not just Europeans ?

Soooo fascinating. We piece together as much as we can about the PIE. They’re shrouded in mystery but at the same time we know so much about them! Really makes you wonder how our ancestors lived and the journeys they made across vast lands

What always confuses me, is that on one hand we use similar sounding words in different languages to find a common ancestor (father, son, mother) but on the other hand, the "oldest words" (dog) seem to go through most changes (hund, dog, pies), and "newer words" go through less (cat, Katze, kot).

Why do you have the zombie survival guide?

Oh another history documentary channel out of the 20 I’m already subscribed to? Yeah I’ll take that any day. Glad I found this! I love love history especially ancient history and the mysteries about people who would’ve been ancient to say Ancient Mesopotamians and Egyptians of the 1st dynasty and so on

Wait. Does this mean that Jehovah didn't break up communication at the Tower of Babel, hence creating the basis for multiple languages? Cuz that would have been dope. Airbody scratchin their head trine nuh figure out what da heck jus happened. Lol

Oh drat! I forgot to make tea. Brb.

The idea of 'hunter/gatherer' people following herds of pre domesticated proto cattle, sheep, goats, pigs, etc is something that just occurred to me today. I had always imagined them hunting mastodon and other mega fauna. It's very likely we also hunted the animals we domesticated prior to domestication. Don't know why I never thought about that before

With no Yamnaya/Steppe dna found amongst Anatolian Indo-Europeans such as the Hittites it seems more likely that Proto-Indo-European originated amongst Caucasian Hunter Gatherers whose dna contributed to both the Anatolians and Western Steppe Herders.

As a native Hindi speaker, I thought the similarities I noticed between my native tongue and English and French was by co-incidence until I learnt that it was by design. 😅

Thanks Jon

Nice.

That was quite interesting! I always vaguely wondered, how we knew anything at all about these ancient cultures. I never considered, that shared apsects of our languages could give us hints about what their generell lifestyle must have been like.

Fantastic video 👏👏

I don't believe that in those days people could speak one single language, because it sounds like nonsense. Languages usually have different dialects, and in those days, when people were very primitive, obviously their language would have been very fragmented into different dialects. Perhaps those ancient dialects later gave rise to new full-fledged languages.

Russian steppe before there were Russians and Russia? An interesting name for a steppe.

Sorry but your maps include all the world, not only indoeurope. If you look at farmery map, you can see real indoeurope: india, persia, mesoptamia, anatolia, balkans, north europe. Just this area is indoeuropean.

Central asia, euroasia, north asia, northeast asia, east asia, southeast asia, austronesia, australia are different as agglutinative speakers. Agglutinative speakers are much more spread than indoeuropeans.

Also, genetics support agglutinative languages by ydna genetic linkages. C2, K2 southeast asians mutated to O1, O2 east asians and C3, N, O3, P1 northern east asians during migrations.

C3, N, O3, P1 were uralic-altaic people and P1 spread to northeast asia into Altai region. They mutated into Q native americans and R central asians during ice age.

Agglutinative speakers may have been living in central asia and have spread to euroasia, south asia even into anatolia. So many languages mixed eachother and formed different languages.

Humans are getting dumber by the minute till the point that education is a complete waste of time.
Indo tells you everything you need to know and modern humans need to stop trying to rewrite world history that was written in stone back when your ancestors were still cockroaches living under rocks.
There was Indochina, Indo-Europe, Indo-Amerika, Indo-Afrika...
The oldest humans are Australian Aboriginals known by several very ancient names: Austral Nword, Habsji, Orang Hitam...
Indo, Indus, Indiër, Native, Country, State, Indiaan, Indien, N-word, are all the same damn words in different Indo languages.
Anything outside of that is racism and Black propaganda.
In order to keep humans divided by race they have to be kept as dumb as humanly possible.
There is no race and stop falling for government bs.

Can you make a video about the indo-uralic hypothesis?

This video contains 10% science and 90% fiction. THe author has got very good phantasy.

I CONDEMN YOU. I LISTENED FROM BEGININ TO THE AND NOT SAY ANY ABOUT KURDISH LENGUGE WHICHES THE OLDEST LENGUAGE OF INDO EUROPIAN AND WITH AROUND 80 MILION PEOPEL NOWADAYS.

I'm not buying it. It is more plausible that the early farmers from the Southern Balkans who transmitted agriculture and husbandry to the west and north were the ones who influenced the languages of the hunter-gatherers. You mentioned the word "butter" as an example. Well, it is an original Greek word and means "cow cheese". The notion that some nomads spoke a more sophisticated language than the farmers of the south, who lived in cities for thousands of years, seems absurd to me.
That what annoys me is this PIE being presented to us as the ultimate truth, when in fact it is hypothetical, completely fabricated, with zero substantial evidence. (you pointed out that it is hypothetical).

I’d be very interested to hear more about “sound splits” (like the one you mentioned at the end of this video) I’m studying speech pathology. 🥰

Except now even David Reich accepts Indo Europeans came from the eastern arc (ie Iran) and moved west.

They were Aryans.

To find the place where the tribe, which spoke proto-Indoeuropean language, we need 2 to establish 2 things:
1. We might reconstruct proto-Indoeuropean vocabulary in regards to certain aspects - climate and weather (snow, ice), animals, birds, insects (like bees), trees, plants, landscape (hills, mountains, rivers) - as the PIE will have words for these things.
2. We can look at the geography of this vocabulary.
Steppe does not have mountains, hence there should be no words for mountains in the PIE, hence steppe or flat areas can't be the place of the original PIE tribe.

Humans were associated with earth?

You mean like how sumerians/akkadians associated humans with earth?

Namaste sir 🕉️🙏

You deserve much more recognition — you have my support & respect good sir

Cordedware is the proto indo-europeans

Atleast mention that 3500 BCE to 2000 BCE script ( Harappan Brahmi) which is likely PROTO SANSKRIT INDO SCRIPT may be your missing PIE

Could you look specifically into the perspective of the possibility that proto-indo-european myths and culture originated and evolved from the Indian subcontinent originally? For example, Indra - Zeus - Thor with the story of fighting against the mythical sea monster... Looking into the Vedic period and Vedic culture?

They sound kinda shitty lol

The hotites

From anatolia

Thank you

Thought provoking. What if our dna did carry language? Hypothetically speaking haha.

The IE theory and the Kurgan hypothesis are lies just like it is a lie that the Iliad and the Odyssey were written 400 years after the Trojan War, as writing did not exist at that time. In the Iliad itself it is mentioned that a folding tablet was used for writing messages. In Book VI of the Iliad, during the Trojan War, the messenger Talthybius brings a folding tablet to Achilles from Agamemnon. The tablet is used to convey Agamemnon's message, which requests that Achilles return to battle. The passage reads:
“Then he set down before him a tablet and stylus and began to speak. 'Son of Peleus,' he said, 'now take it to heart, if any word of mine can find grace with you. Disaster is looming over the whole host of the Achaeans, and you are needed to help them, for the day of doom is at hand." (Iliad, Book VI, lines 252-255)

Saludos.
El misterio de las lenguas y el porqué prácticamente se parecen todas, es porque provienen todas de una misma lengua no escrita pero si hablada por todo el planeta antes de que los Proto-Indeuropeos se dividirieran em grupos por todas direcciones a lo largo de las migraciones.

Investiga sobre el Euskera, la única lengua en el mundo que está alejada de todas las lenguas actuales e Indoeuropeas y al mismo tiempo mantiene vínculo con todas ellas, se considera la lengua más antigua que existe y está relacionada con los Iberos, y estos Iberos tenían descendencia de los antiguos, con ella se pueden descifrar el significado de los pueblos, rios, montañas, echos históricos, dioses, países, ciudades....

Cada vocal representa una fuerza, una energía, por ejemplo la A:
Al hacer resonar la A, observaron que se cristalizaba la energía, siendo la octava superior de la respiración y denotando fuerza y determinación en lo que manifestaba.
La A era la manifestación de los seres y de las cosas desde su fundamento energético y vital. Su semitono derivado: la E.
La E es la creación ya manifiesta, física, no energética pero si vital y nerviosa. Simbolizaba las formas de las cosas y se usaba a menudo para denotar la pluralidad de estas mismas.
La I es la vocal más importante, representa la materialización del pensamiento: una persona.
El sonido O, resonaba en la parte central de todo y desde allí lo inundaba todo de una bien definida sensación de profundidad insondable, daba la imagen de un orificio, un desagüe sin fondo en el cual giraba la energía en espiral.
La U, también sonaba con la profundidad de la O, pero hundiendo sus raíces hacia abajo.

Nuestros antepasados juntaban y conjugaban las vocales creando amplios significados de gran riqueza interpretativa. Así decían OIA
(poniendo énfasis en laA) queriendo expresar que desde el TODO uno viene hacía la manifestación para hacerse visible y patente, y AIO
(con énfasis en la O) era para comunicar que, de lo
manifestado y patente retornaban al TODO abstracto e inmanifiesto. Este es el origen primero de nuestras palabras castellanas HOLA y ADIOS.

Luego tenemos la unión de vocal y consonantes, unificando cada propiedad para obtener el significado final.

Hay terminaciones que cuando conoces su significado puedes obtener mucha información acerca del pasado, pongo algunos ejemplos de terminaciones:
BE, BER, BERE, BELE, PA, PAN, PARE, PABELE, PABERE, BELPA, RA, ARA, BAN, DA, TU, DU, GO, GUE, IO, ITU, BURUGA, GA, GER, GEN,TOL, TUM, KAI, OL, KU, KUR, KULE, KURE, KAR, TAR, TER, SE, SA, IS, IZ, LE, ELE,TURU...

Go & sleep 😴
Albanian language didn’t came from German language
But all European languages have Albanian origin including Latin, Greek Etruscan ect

great great video. have you written any books or articles of your own that you can share or make known to us? I´d LOVE to read them if so. I´m absolutely fascinanted with all of the topics you are addressing (I am still obsessed studying the Lion-man of theHohlenstein-Stadel cave could you revisit the story and help ellaborate on WHY did the make it? I have a few ideas of my own. Fear/awe of the lion- a man killer!- had to play a role there). Watchign your videos is like being in the Wall Mart of the things I want to talk and learn about. Thank you so much for sharing your knowledge and research!!!

Fascinating

Is there any work of comparable depth contemporaneous or earlier than the Rigveda [~3000 BC original ]?

Russian steppe makes sense

Kindly forward these details
To BJP in India