The Murder at Beryl's Dream - Red Dead Redemption 2

I think there isn't any blood on the shirt because the knife hadn't been pulled out.
It's reasonable to assume that the miners worked for a company, and that the company took a hefty cut. Perhaps they were even indentured criminals.
What I think happened is that as they struck gold, the cave partially collapsed. One of the miners decided it would be a grand opportunity to fake death and escape with the gold, stabbed the other one in the back and grabbed what they could, before disappearing into one of the nearby towns or gangs with the haul.

coul;dnt it be that you need to detonate the dynamite while joshua is still there?

Gotta be that guy......a mine shaft is vertical. Horizontal 'tunnels' are called drifts, or if they are in the ore, a stope.

Holy mineshafts, I didn't know about the dynamite and body! oooh back to the game now I reckon.

Some secrets just weren’t meant to be solved

Someone stabbed the guy in the back and missed 1 gold nugget

I’ve found some of the most hidden secrets in rdr2 by pure chance as early as my first playthrough but for some reason I have never once noticed the incredibly obvious detonator at Joshuas camp

Maybe the miner found a gold nugget and got stabbed by someone who didnt want the area to be flooded by gold miners

The ghost story this game

easter eggs have to be the best part of video games

this is so fuckin rad love u fizhy

“ there’s a knife in his back so clearly he had a fall”😂

It's possible that Joshua Brown knew of the gold, but I highly doubt he was the murder. He happens upon Arthur from behind, yet still challenges him to a fair duel instead of shooting him in the back. He also gets mad at Arthur for not killing him with honor, referring to him as a "gut shooter". This to me is enough character evidence to convince me Joshua was not the killer based on his known behavior.

The normal hat lying near the body just cracked me with laugh. One ticket for hell to me i guess.
And then he was punching a man with the miner hat...

Is it possible to do the brown mission and if the detonators there after you shoot the gun out of Brown's Han hogtie him and take him down there to the body ?

That miners hat is great for robbing trains in tunnels.

Can we have long melancholic rdr 2 videos, they are my favorits and i miss them

This is way better and enjoyable than mrbossforthewin

Damn thus man sit posting videos of RDR2?

Love all your videos man!

Wow, never seen that place. I miss some important place since I don't do bounty hunting.

Do a history video on van horn

Awesome, thank you for the video! ❤

He was stabbed than ran off and died elsewhere

love you bro
i hope another game of this caliber drops so we can have more years of content from you

Ethan, the level of research you put into these videos, man I love your channel, I’ve seen a few videos of decades too, you really are an underrated channel. Keep doing what you’re doing man, happy 10 years of Fizhy, have a good one.

I really love your Videos man.. You do a great job💪👍

i was home alone one night and i found the mine, but was too scared to look more into it lol

The killer was after his right shoe. Mystery solved!

can you do a video on the metiorite

Doing another play through of rdr 2 and I’ve been listening to Fizhy the whole time. Just when I thought I was coming to the end of all his playlists he releases this!

It’s awesome to have someone who keeps up with rdr 2 despite rockstar abandoning it…

Rdr 2 online is way better than story mode

funny thing i discovered, if u go to the first gang camp, next to valentine as john it will replay an audio of arthur making fun of him for having a good idea, i dont now if this is new or not, but it literaly made me tear up

I used to live back in strawberry back in those days there was rumors of a death of a miner but knowbody knew if it was true or not thanks to fizhy now as a former resident of strawberry ik what finally happened thank u fizhy

I look forward to these videos

i lost my skins when i get killed

Theory: It was the serial killer Edmund who killed the miner and rigged the explosives so people could see what Edmund claims "his work of art".

I was drunk yesterday. Leaving the like now! 🤙

I’ve played Red Dead 2 ever since it came out and I’m still finding new stuff

Man I've been playing this since release but only found this out a week ago 💀💀

Could you argue that Joshua Brown went to went to beryls dream as he received a tip off that there was wealth in the mine (gold nugs) . Probably from the someone he previously bounty hunted. If he was a common bounty hunter in that area maybe he caught the murderer of the miner in the shaft and the murderer admitted about the wealth as a scheme to get free, Brown due to his desperation to get wealth and escape west Elizabeth he went back to Beryls dream to try and redeem the gold nuggets. (Quite far fetched imo) but I’m new to this!

Good video btw

I learn a lot from your videos and i got a better understanding of the game, thanks mate!!

Ah yes a naturaly growing shelter infront of a man made mine ive seen these grow theyre amazing.

I think this was just one of those things that was just for exploration, no story to be found. Not typical for RDR2 but not impossible 🤷🏻‍♂️

He was murdered by a one legged man who needed his shoe. Case closed🤣

Still learning new things every week about this game. Wow.

On my 4th Tun and I just learned about the miner’s hat. 😲

lol its wild, i literally just finished my first play through last week and im getting recent content