9mm vs 40 vs 45: Can’t Believe The Results

9mm vs 40 vs 45: Can’t Believe The Results

Banana Ballistics

54 года назад

1,276,719 Просмотров

Play World of Warships here: https://wo.ws/4560VFp
Thank you World of Warships for sponsoring this video.
During registration use code DDAY80TH to get a free: 200 doubloons, 1 million credits, 7 Days of Premium Account time, a free ship after you complete 15 battles and 3x special D-day missions after 9 battles (only available for a limited time); Applicable to new users only.

On this episode of Ultimate Barrier Testing, we will be comparing the performance of the 9mm to the 40 S&W and the 45 ACP on 4 different targets. Each target is worth 25 points, for a grand total of 100 points. Whichever cartridge ends up with the highest score will be the winner. Testing was setup at 10 yards. Thanks for watching!

Patreon: https://patreon.com/BananaBallistics?utm_medium=unknown&utm_source=join_link&utm_campaign=creatorshare_creator&utm_content=copyLink

Ammo for tests 1-3 (3 shot average):
CZ p09 - 9mm 115 gr FMJ: 1,168 fps AVG
G22 - 40 S&W 180 gr FMJ FN: 1,044 fps AVG
G21 - 45 ACP 230 gr FMJ: 837 fps AVG

*These tests are meant for entertainment and educational purposes only. Do not try any of these tests at home! Always verify your firearm is rated for and can safely fire any ammunition that you intend to use. Always follow standard safety procedures when handling Any firearm.

#midwayusa

Тэги:

#9mm_vs_45_acp #9mm_vs_40_sw #45_acp_vs_45_auto #40_sw_vs_9mm #40_sw_vs_45_acp #banana_ballistics #ultimate_barrier_testing #9mm_vs_ballistic_gel #40_sw_vs_ballistic_gel #45_acp_vs_ballistic_gel #Why_is_40_S&W_unpopular? #HST_vs_ballistic_gel #147_gr_HST #180_gr_HST #230_gr_HST
Ссылки и html тэги не поддерживаются


Комментарии:

@TThomas-si7yn
@TThomas-si7yn - 22.11.2024 04:55

I only sit through the commercials for channels I support. Otherwise, I'm FForwarding directly through them.
Also, the .40 S&W wound-channel in the ballistic gel was corkscrewed. That was cool AF. Imagine that going through an actual body or part. Done, son.

Ответить
@ryangraham5837
@ryangraham5837 - 22.11.2024 19:16

“The pistol was shooting to the left” is what we all say 😅

Ответить
@StormyShadow-dp3rb
@StormyShadow-dp3rb - 22.11.2024 23:42

Harder for the 45 to go through the wood as it has a larger circumference. Easier for a needle to get through something than an arrow, and easier for an arrow to penetrate than a spear.

Ответить
@DaveO530
@DaveO530 - 23.11.2024 18:21

If you want to do a real test put you jell on a slide and see which bullet moves it the most. Penetration is not everything, a 22 LR will probably penetrate just as much as the center fires.

Ответить
@jst601
@jst601 - 23.11.2024 22:23

Stopping power....knock-down power...the tooth fairy...

Ответить
@MonteHoopla
@MonteHoopla - 24.11.2024 05:45

>40 is designed to have 9mm speed with 45 knock down power... this ism a stupid video

Ответить
@kennethsaunders7108
@kennethsaunders7108 - 25.11.2024 20:18

I don't get the argument? Carry what ya want. JUST carry.

Ответить
@reidgathright3710
@reidgathright3710 - 26.11.2024 05:57

Just came to say get a 10mm. Have a good day.

Ответить
@johndickson435
@johndickson435 - 26.11.2024 12:10

If this is about penetration then it's worthless.

Ответить
@JB54379
@JB54379 - 27.11.2024 01:51

IMO all are amazing with good power ammo. I personally prefer the 9mm because the ammo is cheaper to "target/fun" shoot plus it still packs enough power to stop anyone if you have to, hopefully not though.

Ответить
@MichaelBlackburn-n1y
@MichaelBlackburn-n1y - 27.11.2024 02:33

The only thing I didn't really care for about your test which was it was very interesting is that he was only using non hollow point bullets and well I would like for you to see the test energy delivering power which one delivers the most amount of energy to its on impact to the Target

Ответить
@drewmason2042
@drewmason2042 - 27.11.2024 06:25

Why is he shooting hollow points does not meant for penetration

Ответить
@huaigong8757
@huaigong8757 - 27.11.2024 07:01

A city coroner once wrote his observations from the bodies he sees. The 9mm sometimes bounces off bone. The .40 and .45 just break through the bone and don't deflect.That extra mass makes the difference in humans.

Ответить
@larsharris
@larsharris - 27.11.2024 14:47

For most it’s your frequency of practice that should matter. 9mm is almost always cheaper to buy ammo for. *at least for me*. Reloading 9mm has less concerns *in MY OPINION*. My personal feeling I can go lite loads to +p with little concern. .40 my opinion being extremely careful with loading data is required.
The slight possible improvement some claim in stopping power is not offset for average person. Recoil is slights different. Now if Supressors were not regulated so they cost 5x what they should. I would shoot more .40, & 45 acp. As a 9mm subsonic I don’t like shooting even in non supressed guns.

Ответить
@3onthebeach
@3onthebeach - 28.11.2024 03:17

How's it hangin? A little to the left.

Ответить
@rotorhawk
@rotorhawk - 28.11.2024 19:30

Why can he not hit the middle?

Ответить
@Torchninja
@Torchninja - 30.11.2024 03:09

good stuff....

Ответить
@Beachdude67
@Beachdude67 - 30.11.2024 07:39

The .45 doesn't suck just because it didn't go through lumber. It has more stopping power than either the .40 or 9mm. Personally, if I were to choose between those three weapons for home defense, I'd pick the .45 because it's not likely to go through walls and hit something it isn't supposed to hit.

Ответить
@lorencioalcaraz2623
@lorencioalcaraz2623 - 30.11.2024 09:47

10mm is still king.

Ответить
@BjarneLinetsky
@BjarneLinetsky - 30.11.2024 23:15

I find videos like this to be helpful in understanding the consequences of negligent and purposeful fire in the household environment.

Ответить
@chrispritchard6447
@chrispritchard6447 - 01.12.2024 04:32

Its still similar priced ammunition

Ответить
@Bruce6001
@Bruce6001 - 01.12.2024 08:10

Instead of starting with a 6 inch box of sand you should start with a 2 inch thick box of sand then a 4 inch box of sand then a 6 inch box of sand, you can also use very small pebbles then are great at stopping bullets as well

Ответить
@CuoreScuro
@CuoreScuro - 01.12.2024 20:23

I loved the less clear ballistic gel joke, got a good chuckle.

Ответить
@keijojaanimets4460
@keijojaanimets4460 - 02.12.2024 01:16

Infidel!😁

Ответить
@Therealguymins
@Therealguymins - 02.12.2024 05:05

Why do you complain about the birds? They RULE 8-)

Ответить
@darrellallen3198
@darrellallen3198 - 02.12.2024 06:45

41 is far superior ruger red or black hawk 41 is the sweet spot. not 40 kinda like 20 cal in air rifles is king on bottom end not 177 or 22 mid is 28 cal air rifle is better than a 25 or 30 all around . rare birds for all 3. but superior all things considered . the rem 519..or 523 5mm with peters still holds the fastest fps 5243 or 5343 ? very rare combo and near impossible to find the peters . coyote is doa before he hears the shot up to 300 yrds.

Ответить
@James-z5m4m
@James-z5m4m - 02.12.2024 20:38

The 45 has a larger diameter . The larger diameter bullet takes more velocity to go thru the same amount of lumber. Remember the larger diameter bullet makes a larger hole.

Ответить
@ijinokm
@ijinokm - 02.12.2024 23:36

oookkay, revising my plan to overturn the picnic table as a shield. didn't know they could penetrate that so easily.

Ответить
@CaffeineThrottle
@CaffeineThrottle - 03.12.2024 02:39

The only thing sand is used for is filling bags for high water control or foxhole fortification, time permitting. I haven't ever seen anyone walking around with duct taped boxes hanging on their person, vehicle,home,etc.Maybe a small bucket with lid or milk jug would make your life easier if you must shoot sand. I'm unsubscribing for a break as all your caliber comparisons always end up in a 3 way tie,and Terry needs a damn bath ! 🥱

Ответить
@ronniemaggette1745
@ronniemaggette1745 - 03.12.2024 07:35

I really like these test videos but why are you guys always resusing the same material. If you have 3 guns use 3 separate test pieces for each test so we can see accurate results.

Ответить
@josemariakilayko3052
@josemariakilayko3052 - 03.12.2024 09:39

What an idiot . You have weakend the target after the first round

Ответить
@dickjohnson7845
@dickjohnson7845 - 03.12.2024 21:42

I'd like to see 45 SMC. That has around 1280 FPS.

Ответить
@S7eveThePira7e
@S7eveThePira7e - 05.12.2024 04:04

I love seeing a CZ P09 in any video, one of my personal favorite pistols.

Ответить
@boydstanley6925
@boydstanley6925 - 05.12.2024 06:01

Agree on the 40cal Glock 35

Ответить
@innesleroux9439
@innesleroux9439 - 05.12.2024 17:32

Great video but please linger longer on your text, had to rewind four times to see the Garmin velocity specs...

Ответить
@cnclife2739
@cnclife2739 - 05.12.2024 18:43

Agree!!

Ответить
@jamesmitchell6483
@jamesmitchell6483 - 06.12.2024 16:22

Consider rotating cube clockwise or counter !?!?

Ответить
@frontlinefortificationfind5636
@frontlinefortificationfind5636 - 07.12.2024 14:36

Police & militaries world wide use all of these calibers. They all work just fine when they reach their target.

Ответить
@eag8999
@eag8999 - 08.12.2024 05:35

Redo with highest end underwood ultimate defenders

Ответить
@MyDOOKIE1
@MyDOOKIE1 - 08.12.2024 23:20

"And it has ingredients to moisturize , WOOOWWW"😂

Ответить
@captainsaveahoe
@captainsaveahoe - 09.12.2024 00:33

OOOOOOOOH! OOOOOH!

Ответить
@67daltonknox
@67daltonknox - 09.12.2024 07:18

Thanks... useful.

Ответить
@lehisilver1191
@lehisilver1191 - 09.12.2024 14:10

Do all three of those calibers but add the ten millimeter in

Ответить
@pieronettunoo
@pieronettunoo - 09.12.2024 16:35

...I haven't had such difficulty associating a voice with a body since Rick Astley

Ответить
@lanceyoxtheimer866
@lanceyoxtheimer866 - 10.12.2024 03:41

Bro wood isn't that expensive, use a new piece for each caliber

Ответить
@drifter50038
@drifter50038 - 10.12.2024 17:40

The best takeaway is; the difference in damage is negligible. The Critical focus as always should be on Bullet Placement...

The man who lands his round in a lethal position will, with the Highest probability, defeat the Threat that places its round in a non lethal/non disabling location.

So, train, train, train.

Ответить
@Steve-d1d9f
@Steve-d1d9f - 11.12.2024 02:20

Put a little more finger pad on that trigger.

Ответить
@victorvazquez5200
@victorvazquez5200 - 11.12.2024 04:24

Man the 45 sucks 😂😂😂! At least on lumber !

Ответить